The Supreme Court hears arguments Tuesday in a case that could significantly affect the legal rights of American civilians captured in Iraq.
The dispute tests whether U.S. citizens taken into custody and held by the U.S. military have access to federal courts to challenge their detention. It was brought by two Arab-Americans in custody in Baghdad, one of whom an Iraqi court sentenced to death for an alleged kidnapping.
Normally, U.S. citizens have a right to challenge their detention before a judge. The U.S. government says the men should be denied a hearing because they are officially held by the Multi-National Force-Iraq, a United Nations-mandated force led by the United States but joined by many countries...
Separately detained by American-led military forces in Iraq, Mohammad Munaf and Shwaqi Omar are U.S. citizens who seek access to the basic procedural safeguards afforded by the Constitution – judicial review of their detention through the writ of habeas corpus. Together, both cases ask the Court to adopt a firm rule that allows an American citizen to challenge his or her detention in federal court whenever he or she is held in the custody of American officials...
------
Attorneys for the Bush Administration have argued that the American military personnel detaining Mr. Munaf and Mr. Omar are participating in a multi-national force, and that consequently, United States courts have no jurisdiction to consider the challenges to these detentions. But the executive branch’s position would create perverse incentives to detain American citizens under the auspices of multinational military operations as a way to circumvent judicial review. Contrary to the Administration’s arguments, U.S. authorities should not be permitted to indefinitely hold and interrogate American citizens simply because the arresting forces operate with a United Nations or similar international mandate. Indeed, such interpretations would allow the government to arrest American citizens around the world with impunity and deny them the due process rights afforded by their national judicial system simply by convening the arresting authority under an international charter.
The Supreme Court, in a sweeping rejection of claims of power in the presidency, ruled 6-3 on Tuesday that the President does not have the authority to order states to relax their criminal procedures to obey a ruling of the World Court. The decision came in the case of Medellin v. Texas (06-984). Neither a World Court decision requiring U.S. states to provide new review of criminal cases involving foreign nationals, nor a memo by President Bush seeking to enforce the World Court ruling, preempts state law restrictions on challenges to convictions, the Court said in a ruling written by Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr.
Quote by TriSec:
Everyone stop at noon and look under the buttons and watch the clock tick to 299 days, mmmkay?
Quote by starling310:
Velveeta! Chrisloves
!!!!
PRAISE CHEESUS! And, MRS. CHEESUS TOO!
Quote by Raine:
Good Morning....
I understand. I want this primary over soon and NOW. we have gone from discussing the actual issues to one scandal after another. We once suffered from an embarrassment of issues, now it is just embarrassing.
Quote by starling310:
I find it f*cking comical that we are STILL TALKING ABOUT REVEREND WRIGHT!!!!
![]()
Quote by Raine:
:star: I knew they weren't directed at anyoen here. I do. You dunna need a disclaimer.
Quote by jd_in_ny:
I hate this primary now, too. So depressing.
Quote by starling310:Quote by jd_in_ny:
I hate this primary now, too. So depressing.
Oh no...I am bringin' down da blog.
Quote by BobR:
In a sea of insincerity, Neil Cavuto is Poseidon
Quote by starling310:Quote by jd_in_ny:
I hate this primary now, too. So depressing.
Oh no...I am bringin' down da blog.
Quote by Raine:
No -- the Primary is bringing down the Blog. I keep praying that people will come to thier senses.
Quote by BobR:
Obama goes on vacation, and Hillary sucks all the hope out of the room. When he comes back, it will be like a breath of fresh air. Hopefully, the voters in PA will recognize that.
EDIT: Perhaps they already are...
Quote by starling310:
Tracy Ullman talking about her Citizenship test and how you have to study Civics.
Interesting. . . Naturalized Citizens probably know more than people born into it.
Quote by wickedpam:Quote by starling310:
Tracy Ullman talking about her Citizenship test and how you have to study Civics.
Interesting. . . Naturalized Citizens probably know more than people born into it.
I know two people who have taken the citizenship test and they know vastly more then the average guy on the street about this country. Sad really.
I don't know how people born here can profess to love this country so much and know so little about it.
Quote by livingonli:
If Hillary is going to bring up Pastor Wright, can we bring up her association with "The Family"?
Quote by Raine:Quote by livingonli:
If Hillary is going to bring up Pastor Wright, can we bring up her association with "The Family"?
I am wonderign if Momma has at least READ these articles. Last night on Cavuto, I think it wouold have helped.
Quote by starling310:
:: terry gross :: :sleeping:
:thud:
Quote by livingonli:
If this keeps up, the only way for the Democrats to win the White House would be if the economy collapses, Iraq turns into a total shit-storm and Bush starts bombing Iran as well ensuring a total collapse that would keep anyone with half a brain from voting Republican.
If it comes down to that, this country is fucked.
Quote by velveeta jones:
Frankly, I happen to agree with the Rev........... I don't think its a coincidence that AID's is prevalent in the gay and black communities...... ditto Meth and Crack.
and
![]()
Quote by Raine:
What about Jim Crow? Reparations is all part of the story that caller was mentioning.
Quote by Raine:
Where is it 5 oclock?!?!? These callers are killing me today.
Quote by BobR:Quote by Raine:
What about Jim Crow? Reparations is all part of the story that caller was mentioning.
I disagree with monetary "reparations". Not a good idea...
Quote by starling310:Quote by Raine:
Where is it 5 oclock?!?!? These callers are killing me today.
England? :shrug:
Quote by Raine:
One hold!
Quote by starling310:
"One Hold. One heart. Let's get together and feel alright. . . "
![]()
Quote by TriSec:
:thud:
Quote by velveeta jones:
Uh Oh............... TriSec is down! We need medics and booze........STAT.
Quote by IzzyBitz:
Ya gotta know when to hold em, know when to fold em...
Morning all!
Quote by Raine:I got the booze! We can use his salt to make the margaritas!Quote by velveeta jones:
Uh Oh............... TriSec is down! We need medics and booze........STAT.
Sadly Tri is our blog medic...
Quote by starling310:Quote by Raine:I got the booze! We can use his salt to make the margaritas!Quote by velveeta jones:
Uh Oh............... TriSec is down! We need medics and booze........STAT.
Sadly Tri is our blog medic...
Welp, nothing we can do then. He was a good blogger. :: 'taps' plays in the distance :: Here's to Tri Sec! :: hoists margarita ::
Quote by Raine:
I think we all need this this morning!!!![]()
Quote by velveeta jones:
Upstaged by a friggin' 8 year old...................
:rofl:
Wow.......... that's embarrassing.
Quote by BobR:
Circus of Horrors shut down
Apparently, gypsies are the niggers of Europe. Disgusting...
Quote by TriSec:
The reports of my death have been greatly exaggerated.
Quote by Raine:
I didn't mean to get a but I Did! :party:
Quote by Raine:
I didn't mean to get a but I Did! :party:
Quote by balleryna2:
I'm waaay too shy to call in - I know I will someday - I *have* to! I've written to the show and actually had an email read on the air -- I was the one who said Stephie was right for believing her psychic because (blush) I - too - read tarot cards (yeppers), and I'm not too shy about THAT I guess. (bracing for the onslaught of teasing/jokes now)
Quote by wickedpam:
Thomm needs to ask her if we are a "religious" nation then what religion.
Quote by starling310:
I wonder if Thom goes to break and says "Pfft. Moron."
I would.
Quote by starling310: I have been listening to Thom for 10 minutes and he hasn't mentioned Hillary OR Obama!!! What's the deal THOM!!?!? How dare you talk about.....about....SOMETHING ELSE!
Quote by starling310: I have been listening to Thom for 10 minutes and he hasn't mentioned Hillary OR Obama!!! What's the deal THOM!!?!? How dare you talk about.....about....SOMETHING ELSE!
Quote by starling310:
I have been listening to Thom for 10 minutes and he hasn't mentioned Hillary OR Obama!!! What's the deal THOM!!?!? How dare you talk about.....about....SOMETHING ELSE!
Quote by wickedpam:Quote by starling310:
I wonder if Thom goes to break and says "Pfft. Moron."
I would.
I think he's too polite.
Quote by balleryna2:
I'm wiccan (grew up Methodist) - and have to constantly keep it "private" with most people. My husband's family found out about it in a big way by accident when they came up to visit last summer. Oh the fun. Luckily, everyone was totally cool. It was my sister-in-law who freaked out, but she was finally fine, too.
Quote by balleryna2: I'm wiccan (grew up Methodist) - and have to constantly keep it "private" with most people. My husband's family found out about it in a big way by accident when they came up to visit last summer. Oh the fun. Luckily, everyone was totally cool. It was my sister-in-law who freaked out, but she was finally fine, too.
Quote by balleryna2: I'm waaay too shy to call in - I know I will someday - I *have* to! I've written to the show and actually had an email read on the air -- I was the one who said Stephie was right for believing her psychic because (blush) I - too - read tarot cards (yeppers), and I'm not too shy about THAT I guess. (bracing for the onslaught of teasing/jokes now)
Quote by balleryna2:If it weren't for my fake boobies, I think I'd sink like a rock. I forgot - do witches sink or float??
Quote by balleryna2:
Oh wait, I remember now - they float because "they're made of wood". I guess I'm screwed!
Quote by Raine:You might get teased, Outta caring and the flaven.... but you won't be mocked for your beliefs, not here on this space.Quote by balleryna2:
I'm waaay too shy to call in - I know I will someday - I *have* to! I've written to the show and actually had an email read on the air -- I was the one who said Stephie was right for believing her psychic because (blush) I - too - read tarot cards (yeppers), and I'm not too shy about THAT I guess. (bracing for the onslaught of teasing/jokes now)
Do not ever feel concerned about that. We are a very caring bunch.
Quote by wickedpam:I think he's too polite.Quote by starling310: I wonder if Thom goes to break and says "Pfft. Moron." I would.
Quote by livingonli: Flash 'em if you got 'em.![]()
Quote by Raine:HEY! you too dude!Quote by livingonli:
Flash 'em if you got 'em.![]()
![]()
Quote by starling310:
I am actually really excited about the girl that I have recently started dating. She is Jewish and while I know it isn't DRASTICALLY different from me, it will be interesting to learn about the traditions, etc. She has invited me to a Passover Sadr and I've never been. It's amazing that I am 30 years old and have never personally known a Jewish person until now.
Quote by starling310:
Oh Mondo. .. you poor, darling man. :: fans mondo :: :: smelling salts ::
Quote by Mondobubba:Quote by starling310:
I am actually really excited about the girl that I have recently started dating. She is Jewish and while I know it isn't DRASTICALLY different from me, it will be interesting to learn about the traditions, etc. She has invited me to a Passover Sadr and I've never been. It's amazing that I am 30 years old and have never personally known a Jewish person until now.
You never have know any Jewish folks personally until now?![]()
Quote by balleryna2:
I didn't realize how much there was to learn about the Jewish religion until I lived in Manhattan/Greenwich Village for a couple of years. I had some Jewish friends growing up as a kid, but I was never exposed to it until the mid/late 90's. You will really love it.
Quote by starling310:
Terry Terry Terry......
Oh...this high pitched shill.
I can't take him.
Quote by livingonli:Quote by starling310:
Terry Terry Terry......
Oh...this high pitched shill.
I can't take him.
Why is it whenever he's on Thom, I can only picture Momma and Jim making fun of the way he talks andProducerchris chastising them.
Quote by Raine:
.. someone give monda a hand, I think he has collapsed in the corner....
Quote by starling310:
Shane-O now returns us to our regularly scheduled blog.
:rofl:
Quote by Shane-O:
p.s. I hate that Thom is not on live in Roch-cha-cha (we don't get it here until 9 pm - grr!)
![]()
Quote by jd_in_ny:Quote by Shane-O:
p.s. I hate that Thom is not on live in Roch-cha-cha (we don't get it here until 9 pm - grr!)
![]()
I'm sometimes able to get 1470 out of Ithaca, which airs Thom live, or else go on the internets if I'm able (like now)
sometimes I listen to the Ed, but I just couldn't today.
Quote by jd_in_ny:
Shane-O - that's interesting, because I had 1470 on in the car just after noon, and it was Thom talking about religion and separation of church and state. I was sad when I lost reception, because he was doing so well!
Quote by Raine:
OK. I have a new rule. ALL GOVERNMENT Things should be made in the USA. EVERY GOVERNMETN OFFICE SHOULD BE FORCED TO BUY FROM THE USA. Tough kaka if the governemtn thinks it costs too much. They should be helping out AMERICANS.
Passports being printed in Taiwan is so wrong.
Quote by starling310:
Is Sammy back on the air somewhere, or is he a fill in????
Quote by TriSec:Say now, you lived in New York. Remember when they were building the Acela line between Washington and Boston? Amtrak wanted to buy "off-the-shelf" high-speed trains from France or Germany, but Congress shot them down because Amtrak was required to buy "Made in the USA". Whatever happened to that? (and the Acelas suck, anyway. We would have been better off with German trains...)Quote by Raine: OK. I have a new rule. ALL GOVERNMENT Things should be made in the USA. EVERY GOVERNMETN OFFICE SHOULD BE FORCED TO BUY FROM THE USA. Tough kaka if the governemtn thinks it costs too much. They should be helping out AMERICANS. Passports being printed in Taiwan is so wrong.
Quote by wickedpam:
Alright guys - I'm off on to Clearwater tomorrow - back on Sunday so I'll be back here on Monday. Have a great weekend, I'm gonna miss you guys! :hug:
Quote by TriSec:Quote by Raine:
OK. I have a new rule. ALL GOVERNMENT Things should be made in the USA. EVERY GOVERNMETN OFFICE SHOULD BE FORCED TO BUY FROM THE USA. Tough kaka if the governemtn thinks it costs too much. They should be helping out AMERICANS.
Passports being printed in Taiwan is so wrong.
Say now, you lived in New York. Remember when they were building the Acela line between Washington and Boston? Amtrak wanted to buy "off-the-shelf" high-speed trains from France or Germany, but Congress shot them down because Amtrak was required to buy "Made in the USA".
Whatever happened to that? (and the Acelas suck, anyway. We would have been better off with German trains...)
Quote by Raine::hug: Don't forget the sunscreen! HAve fun Mala! you so very deserve it!Quote by wickedpam:
Alright guys - I'm off on to Clearwater tomorrow - back on Sunday so I'll be back here on Monday. Have a great weekend, I'm gonna miss you guys! :hug:
Quote by livingonli:
Ed Schultz is doing "Shoot the Messenger" this coming Monday.![]()
Ted Rall will be doing April 21st which will be the first day of my vacation. Maybe I will finally be able to go.
Quote by shelaghc:
I already have the trumpet fanfare. Why would you need to record it?
Quote by livingonli:Quote by shelaghc:
I already have the trumpet fanfare. Why would you need to record it?
I had the idea of making it an audicon. It would come in handy sometimes (especially amongst the old Unfiltered Fans).
Quote by shelaghc:
I already have the trumpet fanfare. Why would you need to record it?
Quote by Shane-O:Quote by shelaghc:
I already have the trumpet fanfare. Why would you need to record it?
ugh! -- in what form? -- cuz we've all been "on the case"!!! :)
Quote by shelaghc:Quote by Shane-O:Quote by shelaghc:
I already have the trumpet fanfare. Why would you need to record it?
ugh! -- in what form? -- cuz we've all been "on the case"!!! :)
It's an mp3
Quote by shelaghc:Quote by livingonli:Quote by shelaghc:
I already have the trumpet fanfare. Why would you need to record it?
I had the idea of making it an audicon. It would come in handy sometimes (especially amongst the old Unfiltered Fans).
Do you need me to email it to you?
Quote by shelaghc:
I need an email address to send it to since I don't have any kind of status on the blog other than to add comments.
Quote by shelaghc:
I need an email address to send it to since I don't have any kind of status on the blog other than to add comments.
Quote by Raine:
We are starting up th eKO machine ::: al Franken::: right ka-now....
:ireland: that is awesome tha tyou have that sound!
What did KO say?
Quote by Shane-O:Quote by Raine:
We are starting up th eKO machine ::: al Franken::: right ka-now....
:ireland: that is awesome tha tyou have that sound!
What did KO say?
He did a tease at the top re: Clinton's sleep deprivation vs. answering the 3 am call - and is now doing a segment on it...
Quote by shelaghc:
I need an email address to send it to since I don't have any kind of status on the blog other than to add comments.
Quote by Raine:Maybe KO really DOES listen to Momma!!!Quote by Shane-O:Quote by Raine:
We are starting up th eKO machine ::: al Franken::: right ka-now....
:ireland: that is awesome tha tyou have that sound!
What did KO say?
He did a tease at the top re: Clinton's sleep deprivation vs. answering the 3 am call - and is now doing a segment on it...
I saw the teaser... I felt a little proud!
Quote by Shane-O:Quote by Raine:Maybe KO really DOES listen to Momma!!!Quote by Shane-O:Quote by Raine:
We are starting up th eKO machine ::: al Franken::: right ka-now....
:ireland: that is awesome tha tyou have that sound!
What did KO say?
He did a tease at the top re: Clinton's sleep deprivation vs. answering the 3 am call - and is now doing a segment on it...
I saw the teaser... I felt a little proud!
You should feel that way! -- It wasn't just funny, but an astute observation - no wonder KO picked up on it. If you aren't too uncomfortable with it, could I send your clip from this am along with the KO teaser to Momma - she always loves evidence that Keith listens to her... :)
Quote by Shane-O:Quote by shelaghc:Quote by Shane-O:Quote by shelaghc:
I already have the trumpet fanfare. Why would you need to record it?
ugh! -- in what form? -- cuz we've all been "on the case"!!! :)
It's an mp3
Awesome! -- new toy - and the hunt can be called off!!
![]()
![]()
Thank you shelaghc!
Be bewy bewy quiet - we're huntin' AUDICONS!
Quote by Raine:
DID y'all here that?
KO's fave baseball team is the Yankees... neener neener neener.... Me and Ko sitting in a tree, fans of the ya-ah-kees! :nana:
Quote by starling310:
Seriously...we're going to talk about what the candidate's SPOUSES said!?!?!
:star: is getting hypertension as we speak.
Quote by Raine:
DID y'all here that?
KO's fave baseball team is the Yankees... neener neener neener.... Me and Ko sitting in a tree, fans of the ya-ah-kees! :nana:
Quote by IzzyBitz:
The ideal World Series - The Yankees and The Red Sox. They know how to give good baseball.![]()
Quote by IzzyBitz:
The ideal World Series - The Yankees and The Red Sox. They know how to give good baseball.![]()
Quote by Mondobubba:Quote by Raine:
DID y'all here that?
KO's fave baseball team is the Yankees... neener neener neener.... Me and Ko sitting in a tree, fans of the ya-ah-kees! :nana:
Whatever!
The Yankees suck! They suck more than an Orreck, a Kirby, an Electrolux, and a Dyson all put together. They suck balls, they suck rhino, they suck harder than Pamela Anderson did in her sex tape with Tommy Lee. The SUCK! SUCK SUCK SUCK.
End of rant.
Quote by Raine:So tell us Abotu that JAcksonville team?Quote by Mondobubba:Quote by Raine:
DID y'all here that?
KO's fave baseball team is the Yankees... neener neener neener.... Me and Ko sitting in a tree, fans of the ya-ah-kees! :nana:
Whatever!
The Yankees suck! They suck more than an Orreck, a Kirby, an Electrolux, and a Dyson all put together. They suck balls, they suck rhino, they suck harder than Pamela Anderson did in her sex tape with Tommy Lee. The SUCK! SUCK SUCK SUCK.
End of rant.![]()
:D
Quote by Raine:
Ok, did I just hear PAt Buchana say *My Main Man*???
Hello pat, the 70's called, they want thier cliches back.
Quote by Raine:So tell us Abotu that JAcksonville team?Quote by Mondobubba:Quote by Raine:
DID y'all here that?
KO's fave baseball team is the Yankees... neener neener neener.... Me and Ko sitting in a tree, fans of the ya-ah-kees! :nana:
Whatever!
The Yankees suck! They suck more than an Orreck, a Kirby, an Electrolux, and a Dyson all put together. They suck balls, they suck rhino, they suck harder than Pamela Anderson did in her sex tape with Tommy Lee. The SUCK! SUCK SUCK SUCK.
End of rant.![]()
:D
Quote by Raine:Here :star:ling Darlin'... :martini:Quote by starling310:
Seriously...we're going to talk about what the candidate's SPOUSES said!?!?!
:star: is getting hypertension as we speak.
on the house.
Quote by Raine:
ok so how much more of this PopArt backdrop hell that is called the Dan Abrams show so I have to go thru to see Momma??
(I love pop art, tho, NOT when used on an alleged news magazine... Roy Lichtenstien must be rolling in his grave!!!)
Quote by starling310:
Sticky private area!!! :rofl:
Quote by starling310:
I do not care if Chelsea talks to the press. I care that the press asks the candidates ASK ABOUT THE ISSUES! I know. . . I amtoday.
Quote by Raine:Fr enough. I sorta think that The guys original question was a fair enough one, tho... I think that was a fair question.Quote by starling310:
I do not care if Chelsea talks to the press. I care that the press asks the candidates ASK ABOUT THE ISSUES! I know. . . I amtoday.
Quote by starling310:
I do not care if Chelsea talks to the press. I care that the press asks the candidates ASK ABOUT THE ISSUES! I know. . . I amtoday.
Quote by starling310:Quote by Raine:Fr enough. I sorta think that The guys original question was a fair enough one, tho... I think that was a fair question.Quote by starling310:
I do not care if Chelsea talks to the press. I care that the press asks the candidates ASK ABOUT THE ISSUES! I know. . . I amtoday.
I am inclined to agree with you. I just think all of this qualifying as news is ludicrous.
Quote by Raine:
Quote by starling310:
It's all good. Have a drink on me. :martini:
Quote by IzzyBitz:
Stephanie said pimping out when referring to Chelsea. Jeebus. The MSNBC does not like that term. Is she drunk or just kinda stupid?!![]()
Quote by Raine:
Ok, I CANNOT watch this story.
And hell LArry king has WWE wrestlers?!?!? WTF? WHY does the news end at 9 pm? (AFTER KO)
IT is like the news gets cancelled on cable after a certain time. Pisses me off.... HArumph.
Quote by IzzyBitz:
Dan's show is very TMZish. I don't like it. Talk about beating dead horses. These are such non-issues.
Quote by IzzyBitz:
You can also get the BBC news on the PBS. Me likee. Lewis Black on the Comedy Central tonight as well. I need some laughs after watching the Dan Abrams train wreck.
Quote by TriSec:
Say, I'm watching KO at 10:00 for the first time evah...
Is this live, or is it Memorex?
Quote by Mondobubba:
We are watching Beavis and Butthead on the DVD mosheen.