About Us
Mission Statement
Rules of Conduct
 
Name:
Pswd:
Remember Me
Register
 

American Greatness Explodes Upon Takeoff
Author: BobR    Date: 10/29/2014 11:50:34

About a month back, I wrote a blog lamenting that America no longer did Big Things. In the 60s, as the Cold War ramped up, JFK exhorted us to go to the moon. It was meant to be a symbolic show of the superiority of Capitalism and Democracy over Communism and Authoritarianism. Ultimately, it was an exercise that gave us a lot of jobs and scientific innovation. The space program was a series of steps - from the one man capsules of Mercury, to the two man capsules of Gemini, to the 3 men capsules of Apollo.

After going to the moon seemed to become almost quaint, the Apollo program quietly died, and was replaced by the Space Shuttle. That was meant to be a reusable workhouse, transporting astronauts and cargo to build and maintain a laboratory in permanent earth orbit. It succeeded in its task. However, it too became the victim of its own stagnation, and an increasingly tight-fisted economic mindset that no longer saw the program as a necessity, but simply a costly line item for our nation's budget.

That led us to where we are now. Initially, we had to rely on the Russian and Chinese to ferry supplies and people to and from the space station. Countries who we originally sought to beat into space to show our superiority are now doing that which we used to proudly do ourselves. JFK must be spinning in his grave.

The "brilliant" market-driven mindset solution to this was the Free Market - allowing private companies to take over where NASA once excelled. We certainly used a lot of private companies previously to build our hardware, but it was tightly controlled by the government. Now - we're looking at private taxi service to outer space.

Along the way, technology has grown in leaps and bounds. The phones we carry in our pockets have more computing power than the computers that put a man on the moon. We do less with more. The one thing that hasn't changed since the early days of space exploration is our relationship with gravity. Despite all of technical advances, we still have not figured out how gravity works, and thus must - after all these decades - still use brute force to overcome it. Thus - we still have a need for powerful rocket engines, fueled by explosive liquids.

We were reminded of that reality once again last night as an Antares rocket blew up shortly after takeoff. There is no official explanation as to why yet, and it may be months before all the data and footage and whatever little bits of twisted metal and plastic may be left are analyzed. There were no lives lost, but the costs still loom large - another option into space has been set back and may not survive the perception problem this type of accident creates.

If it turns out to be a problem with the engine, then we as a country have only ourselves to blame. Apparently, there are very few options available for rocket engines, so Orbital Sciences was forced to use a decades-old Russian model:
Orbital Sciences is scrambling to find a liquid-propulsion rocket engine that is in production and available for export to the U.S. to pave the way for its new Antares rocket, the centerpiece of a bid to compete for commercial and government work for decades to come. But just as NASA is finally turning to commercial launch providers, the Virginia-based company is running into roadblocks that jeopardize the rocket's future after only one launch.
[...]
The NK-33 engine that powered Antares' first flight was built decades ago by Russia's Kuznetsov Design Bureau and is no longer in production. Further, Orbital is uncertain about the quality of Aerojet's remaining stockpile of 23 NK-33s, beyond those set aside for NASA's CRS-1. Aerojet Rocketdyne is Orbital's primary subcontractor and overhauls the old NK-33 engines into a configuration for Antares, dubbed AJ-26.

Orbital officials say its only current alternative is the RD-180 engine made in Russia by NPO Energomash. But the United Launch Alliance (ULA), which operates the U.S. Air Force's Atlas V and Delta IV fleets, holds exclusive rights in the U.S. to buy the RD-180.
(bold-face mine)

We no longer make rocket engines here in the U.S.? Companies that design and build rockets don't make their own engines? The notion of outsourcing manufacturing and "sourcing" subcomponents from other manufacturers (generally overseas) is a scab on the soul of American manufacturing, and - as this episode shows - you end up getting what you pay for. In an effort to cut corners - whether to save time or money - the company is facing a costly setback.

And as Americans across the country watched yet another American-made rocket blow up (and having Challenger Disaster flashbacks), we once again showed ourselves and the rest of the world that we don't have the mustard to conquer space anymore. We just want to throw some stuff into the air and collect a paycheck, while other countries focus on making bigger, better, stronger, more sophisticated near-space transports. It will likely be a country other than the U.S. that puts the first man (or woman) on Mars.

That is a shame. It's time for the next Big Thing, and making our own rocket engines would be a good place to start.
 

29 comments (Latest Comment: 10/30/2014 00:13:46 by livingonli)
   Perma Link

Share This!

Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
Technorati

Add a Comment

Please login to add a comment...


Comments:

Order comments Newest to Oldest  Refresh Comments

Comment by Scoopster on 10/29/2014 13:13:39
Mornin' all.. You wanna know what's annoying me today?

http://images.bluegartr.com/bucket/gallery/1251620e47751e03a961e770710caa6f.PNG


Comment by Raine on 10/29/2014 13:17:25
Sombering blog.

Good morning.

Comment by wickedpam on 10/29/2014 13:19:19
Morning

Comment by TriSec on 10/29/2014 13:40:38
All Empires eventually collapse. Leave it to America to go for the perfecta...war, stagnation, financial ruin, infighting. Pretty much every way a country can crumble, we're doing it all at once. Go USA!



Comment by Raine on 10/29/2014 13:45:00
This was published a week ago. There were concerns from Orbital about this engine.

Comment by TriSec on 10/29/2014 14:30:59
Oh, and regarding His Royal Badness, I've finally listened to all of both albums. The one under his name is quite good. 3rd Eye Girl, not so much.

Comment by Will in Chicago on 10/29/2014 15:18:03
Quote by TriSec:
All Empires eventually collapse. Leave it to America to go for the perfecta...war, stagnation, financial ruin, infighting. Pretty much every way a country can crumble, we're doing it all at once. Go USA!



My hope is that we can renew ourselves. While I fear what the elections may bring, there is a sense by many that the system is rigged and most Americans are on the losing end of the game. Perhaps we are in need of a peaceful revolution like the revolution of 1800 and the revolution of 1932, when the nation through the ballot box had a new birth of freedom.


Comment by wickedpam on 10/29/2014 15:42:32
Someone tell me why I know the name Gordie Howe and associate him with the Flyers when he never played for them, esp during the time I watched then in the 70's

Comment by Raine on 10/29/2014 16:18:27
Quote by wickedpam:
Someone tell me why I know the name Gordie Howe and associate him with the Flyers when he never played for them, esp during the time I watched then in the 70's

you listen to the Stephanie Miller show??

Comment by wickedpam on 10/29/2014 16:27:58
Quote by Raine:
Quote by wickedpam:
Someone tell me why I know the name Gordie Howe and associate him with the Flyers when he never played for them, esp during the time I watched then in the 70's

you listen to the Stephanie Miller show??


Did she mention Gordie Howe? He was on the Red Wings and the WHalers.

Comment by Will in Chicago on 10/29/2014 16:30:38


Yes, it is embarrassing. We have a failure of vision. Without a vision of the future, we cannot move forward.



Comment by TriSec on 10/29/2014 16:40:35
Maybe if the rocket was full of Ebola samples somebody might have noticed. Even with the spectacular footage, i think the consensus pick is still to shrug and see what ludicrous program is up next on the telly.

Comment by wickedpam on 10/29/2014 16:41:17
Quote by Will in Chicago:


Yes, it is embarrassing. We have a failure of vision. Without a vision of the future, we cannot move forward.




I thought we were all focused on flying cars.



Comment by Raine on 10/29/2014 17:13:02
keep an eye out around 4:24!!!

Comment by wickedpam on 10/29/2014 17:31:16
Quote by Raine:
keep an eye out around 4:24!!!





look at you two being all subversive and adorable XD

Comment by BobR on 10/29/2014 17:39:49
Quote by wickedpam:
Quote by Raine:
keep an eye out around 4:24!!!



look at you two being all subversive and adorable XD

adorable is the most insidious type of subversive

Comment by TriSec on 10/29/2014 18:11:44
Hey, kids! It's time for TriSec's Tip of the Day!

Don't want Ebola? Don't touch poop!

Good night. Drive safely.

Comment by Mondobubba on 10/29/2014 18:33:29



Sadly Orbital Science uses a lot of Russian tech.

Comment by BobR on 10/29/2014 18:34:43
Quote by TriSec:
Hey, kids! It's time for TriSec's Tip of the Day!

Don't want Ebola? Don't touch poop!

Good night. Drive safely.



Comment by Mondobubba on 10/29/2014 18:53:46
Quote by BobR:
Quote by TriSec:
Hey, kids! It's time for TriSec's Tip of the Day!

Don't want Ebola? Don't touch poop!

Good night. Drive safely.




Why yes I often eat mucus I find on the street. How about you?

Comment by Raine on 10/29/2014 19:11:19
Comment by BobR on 10/29/2014 19:41:23

He was on some stupid reality show about 10-15 years ago. He didn't seem like a very bright bulb then.

Comment by Mondobubba on 10/29/2014 19:51:34



Kids, this is what steroids can do, make you stupid.

Comment by Raine on 10/29/2014 19:51:45
Here Mondo, HAve fun. (the snark is strong with this one)

Comment by Mondobubba on 10/29/2014 19:57:35
Quote by Raine:
Here Mondo, HAve fun. (the snark is strong with this one)



Thank you for the PSA, Raine. It was most informative!

Comment by Raine on 10/29/2014 21:07:54
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Raine:
Here Mondo, HAve fun. (the snark is strong with this one)



Thank you for the PSA, Raine. It was most informative!
Glad to help.

now onto other plans… looking at you Buzzplay…

Comment by Mondobubba on 10/29/2014 21:15:56
Quote by Raine:
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Raine:
Here Mondo, HAve fun. (the snark is strong with this one)



Thank you for the PSA, Raine. It was most informative!
Glad to help.

now onto other plans… looking at you Buzzplay…





Comment by livingonli on 10/30/2014 00:13:46
Joan Jett singing the National Anthem at the Knicks opener.