About Us
Mission Statement
Rules of Conduct
 
Name:
Pswd:
Remember Me
Register
 

Music Has No Race
Author: BobR    Date: 2015-02-11 11:56:12

The music business is strange. It is an industry where an artist (or - generally - a team of artists and technicians) create music, which is then copied to meet demand and sold. There are no singular "one of a kind" pieces of work - the very nature of it is that it can be duplicated exactly. A well written song or concerto is replayed and re-recorded through the years by various other artists who are touched by the original composition.

In modern music, though, success and recognition is often add odds with the originality of the work, and the skill of the performer. Talented musicians watch in despair as less talented and creative-impaired contemporaries capture the attention of the fickle music-consuming public, and become wildly rich and successfully. Being attractive and willing to dress provocatively certainly helps.

Which is why shows like the Grammys must be taken with a certain grain of salt. So much good music never floats to the top, while cult of personality provides instant publicity for what becomes "pop" music. This is why old farts like me often look and listen to the nominated songs, artists, and performances and think "Really?... this is the best of the best?".

When Kanye West nearly reprised his Taylor Swift debacle (and in fact later on did), he claimed that Beyonce's album was better than Beck's. Never mind that Beck is a multi-instrumentalist who writes, performs, records, and produces his own songs, and Beyonce is essentially just a singer and a dancer (although undeniably talented and very good at what she does). For Kanye to claim that Beck doesn't respect artistry in music is absurd, laughable, and a bit sad. Perhaps Kanye should remember that what appeals to him in music, and what he considers talent may differ from what others (those who voted for Beck) consider worthy of recognition.

As an echo from the Oscars, there also seemed to be hint of racism, that a white guy was chosen over a black woman. Unlike the Oscars, however, the Grammy nominations and final votes are cast by members of NARAS. Anyone in the music business can join NARAS and vote. The Grammys are truly honorifics bestowed by peers upon peers. If an artist or their music makes it to "the finals", it's because the artists you hear on the radio and see on TV are the ones that put them there.

The whispers of racism in the music business are absurd - music has no color. The music business was one of the first racially-integrated industries in this country. Musicians didn't care about the color of the person playing next to them, as long they could play. The same went for recording studios and people selling records. When a musician hears new music or styles they haven't heard before, and it touches them in some way, they want to learn about it and try to play it, and it ends up becoming part of their unique voice.

The Rolling Stones discovered the music of old blues musicians and loved them so much, they recorded a number of their songs on their early albums. They took notes and tried to emulate some the things they heard. There are those who say they "stole" the music of these old blues men, but at the same time they brought them and their music to new ears who never would have heard them. The Stones and other bands like them were cheerleaders for this music.

And so through the following decades the color barriers elsewhere were not found in music. White musicians played blues and funk, black musicians played rock and roll, and became opera and country singers. The music lovers didn't care about the race of the musician, so long as they delivered the goods. The Swampers in Muscle Shoals were a bunch of white southern guys playing with black singers, and no one cared nor knew the difference - just ask Aretha Franklin.

When rap first gained popularity, the possibilities were endless as much as the styles were varied. The styles ranged from Public Enemy to Run DMC to the Sugar Hill Gang to the Beastie Boys. I personally was never really much of fan (preferring singing), but Public Enemy and Outkast and the Beasties still appealed to me for various reasons. It seems a shame that for the most part it's been dumbed down to the lowest common denominator for commerce's sake, just like numerous other musical movements before and after.

Still - rap is style of music that was long considered "black" (or "urban", if you prefer). Perhaps that's why there was so much gnashing of teeth over Iggy Azalea's nomination. She - being a white Australian - was doing Atlanta rap, and many saw it verging on a minstrel show:
“The New Classic” doesn't feel like a collection of rap songs so much as a cartoonish performance of race. It’s heavy on gloating and boilerplate tough-talk, nearly all of which lacks humor or a distinctive point of view.

As for her delivery, it’s a needling imitation of a black Southern voice, with syllables that twang in the wrong direction and vowels that curve into sour shapes. It’s pantomime devoid of personality. An empty white echo.

As a musician myself who loves funk and soul (but can't play it worth a damn), I understand trying to emulate those whose music you admire, whether it means appropriating the dress, the style of singing, of posing or dancing, and of songwriting. I will give Iggy Azalea the benefit of the doubt. I don't think she was trying to rip off the black Atlanta rap culture - I think she loves it so much she wants to be it.

The real problem with her being nominated (in my view) is that she does it so badly. I've seen and heard her only a few times, and it was enough for me. She's annoying and hard to listen to. I have to wonder what contemporaries of hers in NARAS liked her enough to not only get her initially nominated, but to get her into the final vote.

As it turns out, a different white rapper won best rap album, and not for the first time. I haven't heard anyone complain about his "ripping off black culture". I don't hear about it when another musical abortion - Justin Bieber - does the same thing. It makes me wonder - is it okay when a guy does it?

I'll say it again - music has no color. Race is a human construct that seems an antiquated notion. It certainly has no place in music, as music knows no boundaries. We may all dance to the beat of a different drummer, but as long as we dance, it doesn't matter. Who created what doesn't matter - what matters is who does it well and with heart. Let's reward that and erase the false lines that limit and pigeonhole and divide us all.
 

29 comments (Latest Comment: 02/11/2015 23:33:21 by livingonli)
   Perma Link

Share This!

Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
Technorati

Add a Comment

Please login to add a comment...


Comments:

Order comments Newest to Oldest  Refresh Comments

Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2015 12:43:38
Morning all.

Comment by Scoopster on 02/11/2015 13:20:24
Mornin' all!

Said it before, saying it again. With all respect to Beck, Morning Phase sucked and the Arctic Monkeys should have been nominated and won.

Comment by Scoopster on 02/11/2015 13:22:07
Also.. LIZZ WINSTEAD FOR DAILY SHOW HOST!!!

(or John Fugelsang)

Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2015 13:23:35
Here's a little quote from a friend of mine on Facebook who's a musician, music writer and owner of the most massive record collection I have ever seen.

those denigrating the artistry of Beyonce Knowles vs. Beck because of the collaborative nature of much of the composing involved -- what are your feelings then of Motown Records during its glory days? Or Phil Spector productions. Or Stax/Volt, etc?


Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2015 13:24:08
Quote by Scoopster:
Also.. LIZZ WINSTEAD FOR DAILY SHOW HOST!!!

(or John Fugelsang)



Eh, she was already a special correspondent, plus she created the damn show.

Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2015 14:14:51



Mine come automatically, Scoop. Can't wait to see how long it takes to download and install now.

Comment by TriSec on 02/11/2015 14:29:08
All music is created equal. If it sounds good, it is good.

To this day, there are some musicians that I have no idea if they are white, black, brown, or purple. I like their music, and have yet to be inclined to look up a picture of the artist in question.



Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2015 14:37:06
Morning

Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 14:51:18
good morning!

Comment by TriSec on 02/11/2015 15:29:25
If Aaron Hernandez were to be buried under a snow mound until June, I think we'd all be better off. It's getting "Trial of the Century" coverage here. Does anyone outside Route 128 even know what this is about?

Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 15:53:14
I think I figured out what bothers me, with regards to the blog. It's a really good one, btw, Babe.

Music has no race, to that I totally agree.

However if you take the music part out of it. That still leaves a race problem.

The other day, I posted a link about a rare speech that Bob Dylan gave. He was honored by an organization called Music Cares.

Bob Talked — for 40 minutes. HE mentioned that his music didn't come out of thin air. He paid tribute that his music was born from the road others have lead.

Bob and I disagreed slightly about Iggy azalea in particular.
The real problem with her being nominated (in my view) is that she does it so badly. I've seen and heard her only a few times, and it was enough for me. She's annoying and hard to listen to. I have to wonder what contemporaries of hers in NARAS liked her enough to not only get her initially nominated, but to get her into the final vote.
HE's right, but I think the problem here is less Azalea and more the people who embrace her as a rapper. The fans, I guess.

There has been a lot of discussion about appropriation of a culture and/or Co-pting it. It's hard to put a finger on it. It's difficult to discuss without sounding like a hypocrite.

It's not that she'e a rapper. or pretending to be a blackish person. The problem is she can go back to being a white Australian woman at any point. She can turn it off. She can go back to her social status (for lack of a better phrase) any time she wants. I feel the same way about Beiber — So I guess in a way yes, we maybe harder on women. That could be the overall misogyny we see in society. There are people who really see the race problem with her in particular.

It's not the music, it's the act. It almost reminds me of blackface, without the actual back face.

Eminem and the Beasty boys grew up with the culture they sang of. They aren't pretending. We don't give Darius Rucker a hard time because he's not acting his music. He's not pretending to be someone who he is not.

The same goes for Bob Dylan — or Beck, because they aren't making it about Race.












Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 15:59:14
Quote by TriSec:
If Aaron Hernandez were to be buried under a snow mound until June, I think we'd all be better off. It's getting "Trial of the Century" coverage here. Does anyone outside Route 128 even know what this is about?

It barely makes the news around here.

Comment by BobR on 02/11/2015 16:00:29
Quote by Raine:
I think I figured out what bothers me, with regards to the blog. It's a really good one, btw, Babe.

No music has no race, to that I totally agree.

However if you take the music part out of it. That still leaves a race problem.

The other day, I posted a link about a rare speech that Bob Dylan gave. He was honored by an organization called Music Cares.

Bob Talked — for 40 minutes. HE mentioned that his music didn't come out of thin air. He paid tribute that his music was born from the road others have lead.

Bob and I disagreed slightly about Iggy azalea in particular.
The real problem with her being nominated (in my view) is that she does it so badly. I've seen and heard her only a few times, and it was enough for me. She's annoying and hard to listen to. I have to wonder what contemporaries of hers in NARAS liked her enough to not only get her initially nominated, but to get her into the final vote.
HE's right, but I think the problem here is less Azalea and more the people who embrace her as a rapper. The fans, I guess.

There has been a lot of discussion about appropriation of a culture and/or Co-pting it. It's hard to put a finger on it. It's difficult to discuss without sounding like a hypocrite.

It's not that she'e a rapper. or pretending to be a blackish person. The problem is she can go back to being a white Australian woman at any point. She can turn it off. She can go back to her social status (for lack of a better phrase) any time she wants. I feel the same way about Beiber — So I guess in a way yes, we maybe harder on women. That could be the overall misogyny we see in society. There are people who really see the race problem with her in particular.

It's not the music, it's the act. It almost reminds me of blackface, without the actual back face.

Eminem and the Beasty boys grew up with the culture they sang of. They aren't pretending. We don't give Darius Rucker a hard time because he's not acting his music. He's not pretending to be someone who he is not.

The same goes for Bob Dylan — or Beck, because they aren't making it about Race.

I have a hard time with the term "appropriation" when it comes to music. I tried to make the point in the blog that every musician appropriates what they like in their predecessors and their contemporaries. Everyone takes bits and pieces of what others are doing. Even the greats and the originators learned and copied others.

As to Azalea being able to "turn it off", the same goes for any performer. Does Alice Cooper sit around the house in lizard pants and makeup? No - it's all for show. I guess I just don't have a problem with her "acting black", any more than I have a problem with a black performer "acting white". As long as it's not mean-spirited and hateful anyway.

Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2015 16:02:57
Quote by Raine:
I think I figured out what bothers me, with regards to the blog. It's a really good one, btw, Babe.

Music has no race, to that I totally agree.

However if you take the music part out of it. That still leaves a race problem.

The other day, I posted a link about a rare speech that Bob Dylan gave. He was honored by an organization called Music Cares.

Bob Talked — for 40 minutes. HE mentioned that his music didn't come out of thin air. He paid tribute that his music was born from the road others have lead.

Bob and I disagreed slightly about Iggy azalea in particular.
The real problem with her being nominated (in my view) is that she does it so badly. I've seen and heard her only a few times, and it was enough for me. She's annoying and hard to listen to. I have to wonder what contemporaries of hers in NARAS liked her enough to not only get her initially nominated, but to get her into the final vote.
HE's right, but I think the problem here is less Azalea and more the people who embrace her as a rapper. The fans, I guess.

There has been a lot of discussion about appropriation of a culture and/or Co-pting it. It's hard to put a finger on it. It's difficult to discuss without sounding like a hypocrite.

It's not that she'e a rapper. or pretending to be a blackish person. The problem is she can go back to being a white Australian woman at any point. She can turn it off. She can go back to her social status (for lack of a better phrase) any time she wants. I feel the same way about Beiber — So I guess in a way yes, we maybe harder on women. That could be the overall misogyny we see in society. There are people who really see the race problem with her in particular.

It's not the music, it's the act. It almost reminds me of blackface, without the actual back face.

Eminem and the Beasty boys grew up with the culture they sang of. They aren't pretending. We don't give Darius Rucker a hard time because he's not acting his music. He's not pretending to be someone who he is not.

The same goes for Bob Dylan — or Beck, because they aren't making it about Race.








We also don't give Adele a hard time. Part of me thinks its a case by case basis thing.


Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 16:09:44
Quote by wickedpam:
Quote by Raine:
I think I figured out what bothers me, with regards to the blog. It's a really good one, btw, Babe.

Music has no race, to that I totally agree.

However if you take the music part out of it. That still leaves a race problem.

The other day, I posted a link about a rare speech that Bob Dylan gave. He was honored by an organization called Music Cares.

Bob Talked — for 40 minutes. HE mentioned that his music didn't come out of thin air. He paid tribute that his music was born from the road others have lead.

Bob and I disagreed slightly about Iggy azalea in particular.
The real problem with her being nominated (in my view) is that she does it so badly. I've seen and heard her only a few times, and it was enough for me. She's annoying and hard to listen to. I have to wonder what contemporaries of hers in NARAS liked her enough to not only get her initially nominated, but to get her into the final vote.
HE's right, but I think the problem here is less Azalea and more the people who embrace her as a rapper. The fans, I guess.

There has been a lot of discussion about appropriation of a culture and/or Co-pting it. It's hard to put a finger on it. It's difficult to discuss without sounding like a hypocrite.

It's not that she'e a rapper. or pretending to be a blackish person. The problem is she can go back to being a white Australian woman at any point. She can turn it off. She can go back to her social status (for lack of a better phrase) any time she wants. I feel the same way about Beiber — So I guess in a way yes, we maybe harder on women. That could be the overall misogyny we see in society. There are people who really see the race problem with her in particular.

It's not the music, it's the act. It almost reminds me of blackface, without the actual back face.

Eminem and the Beasty boys grew up with the culture they sang of. They aren't pretending. We don't give Darius Rucker a hard time because he's not acting his music. He's not pretending to be someone who he is not.

The same goes for Bob Dylan — or Beck, because they aren't making it about Race.








We also don't give Adele a hard time. Part of me thinks its a case by case basis thing.
I felt this way about Miley Cyrus last year at the VMA;s — I think it's the performances that are bugging me.

I know that Bob is talking about the music itself and I don;t want to take anything away from that. I personally have a hard time not seeing it from a socio-cultural thing.

Iggy can stop pretending to be black anytime. I don't see Adele pretending to be black,

Black people can't stop being black. I know that this is where Bob and I sorta part ways about this.



Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 16:20:25
oh and Kanye is still a Jackass.


Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 17:22:02
Kanye killed the blog.

Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2015 17:33:15
Quote by Raine:
Kanye killed the blog.



cause he's a jackass

Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 17:34:44
Quote by wickedpam:
Quote by Raine:
Kanye killed the blog.



cause he's a jackass
boom!




Comment by Scoopster on 02/11/2015 18:08:55
Hey Mother Nature

http://images.bluegartr.com/bucket/gallery/2bf119fda4fb83bc118ea2eec5dca934.jpg


Comment by Scoopster on 02/11/2015 18:11:43
Damnit I thought we had a middle finger emote!

Comment by TriSec on 02/11/2015 18:16:47
I'd almost rather those poor students in NC be shot for being Muslim than over a friggin' parking spot...

Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 19:00:10
Quote by TriSec:
I'd almost rather those poor students in NC be shot for being Muslim than over a friggin' parking spot...

What?

I heard the shooter was pretty atheist.

if he shot those people over a parking space, I would actually be relieved. here is why:

The media decided to focus on religion as opposed to the story itself.

People are dead and they should not be dead.



Comment by livingonli on 02/11/2015 19:02:31
What is pushed for hip-hop if you go by what is played on urban contemporary radio and the music video channels seems to be mostly be the celebration of money, having the most "bitches" and trying to prove what a bad ass you are. There is still socially conscious and political hip-hop but it's not pushed and doesn't get airplay.

Comment by Raine on 02/11/2015 19:21:20
Quote by Scoopster:
Damnit I thought we had a middle finger emote!

Find me one and I can make it happen.

IT will be :FU:

Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2015 19:38:48
Quote by Scoopster:
Hey Mother Nature

http://images.bluegartr.com/bucket/gallery/2bf119fda4fb83bc118ea2eec5dca934.jpg



Scoop I know it isn't an emoticon, but will this do in this case?

https://jygersrant.files.wordpress.com/2013/05/lois-lane-04.jpg


Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2015 19:41:26
Okay I just went form eh to you are the man, Sir on the customer I am listening to. He Quoted Bowie.

Comment by livingonli on 02/11/2015 23:33:21
It sure got quiet here.