About Us
Mission Statement
Rules of Conduct
 
Name:
Pswd:
Remember Me
Register
 

Crisis? What Crisis?
Author: BobR    Date: 03/24/2021 13:03:45

To hear the news pundits tell it, as soon as President Biden took office, there suddenly magically was a crisis occurring at the border. You'd expect that from FOX "News" (neither fair nor balanced), where their relationship with the truth is tenuous at best.

But even REAL news outlets, are using the same phrase "crisis" to describe what is happening there. ABC News titles their article "U.S. trying to dissuade migrant travel to ease growing border crisis". The NY Post says "VP Harris appears to blame Trump administration for border crisis".

Republican Rep Madison Cawthorn (R-SC) (yes, that's his real name), has even made the outrageous claim that
"The Biden Admin just dropped $86 Million dollars to get hotel rooms for ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS yet we have zero dollars going to our homeless veterans who are at a high risk of suicide. UNACCEPTABLE. UNAMERICAN".
This is in reference to a federal contract to house some migrant families, rather than PUT THE KIDS IN CAGES AND EJECT THEIR PARENTS. The claim by Cawthorn is not true, FWIW, because the current budget - which Cawthorn voted against - contains more than two billion dollars to address homeless veterans.

Besides keeping families together, the Biden administration is requesting that unaccompanied migrant children be housed at a couple military bases until a permanent home can be found

Reminder: the border facility used by the ex-administration to split up families and warehouse kids was put in place to temporarily house unaccompanied children. That was a distinction ignored by Republicans when they said "Obama did it too". Biden is trying to repair that crime against humanity by allowing families to reunite with their kids in the U.S.. As of the end of February, 112 families had been reunited.

What with all the misleading and downright false claims being tossed around, the Washington Post dispenses with alarmism, and goes with research and data (remember when news organizations used to do that?). They build a very solid case for why this is not a crisis:
In the figure below, we combine data from fiscal year 2012 to fiscal year 2020 to show the cumulative total number of apprehensions for each month over these eight years. As you can see, migrants start coming when winter ends and the weather gets a bit warmer. We see a regular increase not just from January to February, but from February to March, March to April, and April to May — and then a sharp drop-off, as migrants stop coming in the hotter summer months when the desert is deadly. That means we should expect decreases from May to June and June to July.

http://www.FourFreedomsBlog.com/uploads/ImmigrantTotals.PNG

(much more at link)

Why would it be cyclical though? The answer to that is on your dinner table. Migrants cross the border (many "illegally") to work on farms during the harvest season, and then return home for the winter. The xenophobic harsh enforcement of immigration laws at our southern border has created a labor crisis for our farmers for the last several years. It's possible to get farm labor via the H-2A program, but it's not currently a viable solution:
... why don’t more farmers use the H-2A program? It’s expensive and inefficient.

[...]

H-2A requires farmers to pay above-market wages on top of providing free housing and transportation to and from the farm. At that rate, it’s difficult for a farmer to make ends meet.

Then there are the delays farmers often experience in getting workers. If it takes too long to process an H-2A application or if the farmer makes the slightest mistake on the paperwork, workers might not arrive in time—and every day of delay matters when crops are ripe.

Finally, H-2A is a seasonal worker program, giving year-round producers almost no options.

Let's also dispense with the old trope that immigrants are taking jobs from Americans. At one point (about 100 years ago), most farm labor was performed by transients moving from one farm to another to harvest. They got fed up with poor working conditions and poor pay, and slowly it became one of those "jobs Americans just don't want to do". With temp farm labor paying around $15/hr in California, it's hard to get anyone - even illegal immigrants - to hire.

It's way past time for immigration reform. It makes sense for economic and humanitarian reasons. We spend so much money on manpower, technology, and infrastructure to keep a needed workforce from entering the country. This should be replaced with an easy and efficient system for matching farmers with workers trying to enter.

This is a "crisis" of our own making.
 
 

11 comments (Latest Comment: 03/24/2021 15:09:07 by livingonli)
   Perma Link

Share This!

Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
Technorati

Add a Comment

Please login to add a comment...


Comments:

Order comments Newest to Oldest  Refresh Comments

Comment by Raine on 03/24/2021 13:39:34
Good morning and AMEN!

Comment by wickedpam on 03/24/2021 13:45:31
Morning

OT thought - Madison Cawthorne - the millennial name for Boss Hogg. That is one serious southern villain name.

Comment by Raine on 03/24/2021 13:53:45
Quote by wickedpam:
Morning

OT thought - Madison Cawthorne - the millennial name for Boss Hogg. That is one serious southern villain name.

PERFECT!

Comment by wickedpam on 03/24/2021 14:04:40
Quote by Raine:
Quote by wickedpam:
Morning

OT thought - Madison Cawthorne - the millennial name for Boss Hogg. That is one serious southern villain name.

PERFECT!



Right? Totally expect that guy to foreclose on your nana's home, and they kick puppies.

Comment by Scoopster on 03/24/2021 14:13:01
Mornin' all!

I have never understood the ridiculous argument that "now is not the time to talk about this".

They've literally been saying that since Columbine, and we still had the Brady law then!

22 years of being the wrong time. We waited long enough. Far too many dead children.

Comment by wickedpam on 03/24/2021 14:22:22
Quote by Scoopster:
Mornin' all!

I have never understood the ridiculous argument that "now is not the time to talk about this".

They've literally been saying that since Columbine, and we still had the Brady law then!

22 years of being the wrong time. We waited long enough. Far too many dead children.


Man, just saying to someone that the first mass shooting I remember is Luby's. We've waited way, way, way too long to talk about gun culture in this country.


Comment by TriSec on 03/24/2021 14:33:52
Good morning.

A line was crossed last Saturday, and I now regret that war has come to the gates of the TriSec compound.

Last Saturday, March 20. First day of Spring, but you may also be aware that Papa TriSec turned 87.

We're still Covidian, so I made Corned Beef and Cabbage, and put some in a takeaway box and drove over to visit. Brought him some Guinness, too - which was greatly appreciated.

Brother TriSec did not make the trek from New Hampshire, but did call Pops later to pass on birthday greetings.

I come to find out - during the call, he started spouting Trumpian rhetoric at our father. Pops, long past the point of no return, was having none of it and told him where he could get off.

On his fucking birthday.

As the nation retreated into darkness, I started cutting off anyone I decided was a fascist. It didn't matter to me - friends, family, co-workers - if I could determine where you stood based on your facebook postings, I made the decision for you.

The only person who had a "pass" was my own brother.

That exemption has expired today. I did NOT tell him what Pops did, nor did I actually unfriend and block like I did nearly everyone else, but he has been unfollowed.

In some ways, Covid made this easy - I hadn't spoken to him in over a year anyway.



Comment by TriSec on 03/24/2021 14:34:23
Quote by TriSec:
Good morning.

A line was crossed last Saturday, and I now regret that war has come to the gates of the TriSec compound.

Last Saturday, March 20. First day of Spring, but you may also be aware that Papa TriSec turned 87.

We're still Covidian, so I made Corned Beef and Cabbage, and put some in a takeaway box and drove over to visit. Brought him some Guinness, too - which was greatly appreciated.

Brother TriSec did not make the trek from New Hampshire, but did call Pops later to pass on birthday greetings.

I come to find out - during the call, he started spouting Trumpian rhetoric at our father. Pops, long past the point of no return, was having none of it and told him where he could get off.

On his fucking birthday.

As the nation retreated into darkness, I started cutting off anyone I decided was a fascist. It didn't matter to me - friends, family, co-workers - if I could determine where you stood based on your facebook postings, I made the decision for you.

The only person who had a "pass" was my own brother.

That exemption has expired today. I did NOT tell him why, nor did I actually unfriend and block like I did nearly everyone else, but he has been unfollowed.

In some ways, Covid made this easy - I hadn't spoken to him in over a year anyway.




Comment by Raine on 03/24/2021 14:55:29
Quote by TriSec:
Good morning.

A line was crossed last Saturday, and I now regret that war has come to the gates of the TriSec compound.

Last Saturday, March 20. First day of Spring, but you may also be aware that Papa TriSec turned 87.

We're still Covidian, so I made Corned Beef and Cabbage, and put some in a takeaway box and drove over to visit. Brought him some Guinness, too - which was greatly appreciated.

Brother TriSec did not make the trek from New Hampshire, but did call Pops later to pass on birthday greetings.

I come to find out - during the call, he started spouting Trumpian rhetoric at our father. Pops, long past the point of no return, was having none of it and told him where he could get off.

On his fucking birthday.

As the nation retreated into darkness, I started cutting off anyone I decided was a fascist. It didn't matter to me - friends, family, co-workers - if I could determine where you stood based on your facebook postings, I made the decision for you.

The only person who had a "pass" was my own brother.

That exemption has expired today. I did NOT tell him what Pops did, nor did I actually unfriend and block like I did nearly everyone else, but he has been unfollowed.

In some ways, Covid made this easy - I hadn't spoken to him in over a year anyway.

This situation is something I am afraid of in my family. I'm sorry that happened.


Comment by Raine on 03/24/2021 14:57:47
Quote by Scoopster:
Mornin' all!

I have never understood the ridiculous argument that "now is not the time to talk about this".

They've literally been saying that since Columbine, and we still had the Brady law then!

22 years of being the wrong time. We waited long enough. Far too many dead children.

Hey Scoop, How are you doing?

Comment by livingonli on 03/24/2021 15:09:07
Quote by wickedpam:
Quote by Raine:
Quote by wickedpam:
Morning

OT thought - Madison Cawthorne - the millennial name for Boss Hogg. That is one serious southern villain name.

PERFECT!



Right? Totally expect that guy to foreclose on your nana's home, and they kick puppies.

He took a trip to visit Hitler's vacation home in Germany which was near one of the old concentration camps. Amazing how many Trumpsters seem to relate to Hitler.