About Us
Mission Statement
Rules of Conduct
 
Name:
Pswd:
Remember Me
Register
 

Something about RomneyCare
Author: TriSec    Date: 08/22/2009 11:55:23

Good Morning!

Well, it's been quite a week. As most of you know, I'm on new job number two for 2009, and have spent all of the last week in training (and away from dear bloggie!). Next week it's more of the same, only I'll be with my team and learning what it is I'm *actually* supposed to do.

I'll be eligible for benefits in 30 days, which comes as a great relief. I've been on COBRA since February. You know I live in the only state that has a mandated (and unfunded) universal health care requirement. The way Mitt had the law written, everyone in this Commonwealth is required to purchase healthcare. We get a little document from our carrier every year at tax time stating this, or we face a major tax hit. (Yes, we're penalized if we don't have insurance.)

In order to make it 'easier' for folks to comply, Herr Romney created something called the Commonwealth Connector. All the insurance providers in Massachusetts got together and tried to come up with some 'affordable' options for people to buy. Why doesn't everyone take a minute to check it out. Click on the 'find insurance' button and pretend you live here. How much does your plan cost? (remember, that's out-of-pocket to you.)

When I was first out of work, I priced several plans. One of the options wound up being about $100 less than my COBRA payment, but as I read further into it, the copays, deductibles, and other patient responsibilities kept adding up and it didn't make sense to switch. In the end, we qualified for ARRA payments and have been paying roughly what I would normally contribute in an employer-based plan.

But is RomneyCare working? It's true that the majority of persons in the Commonwealth are covered, but at what cost?




Massachusetts has the most expensive family health insurance premiums in the country, according to a new analysis that highlights the state’s challenge in trying to rein in medical costs after passage of a landmark 2006 law that mandated coverage for nearly everyone.

The report by the Commonwealth Fund, a nonprofit health care foundation, showed that the average family premium for plans offered by employers in Massachusetts was $13,788 in 2008, 40 percent higher than in 2003. Over the same period, premiums nationwide rose an average of 33 percent.

The report did not break out how much premiums have increased in Massachusetts since the 2006 changes went into effect, so it does not show whether the law affected the rate of price increases. Still, with the state’s law often cited as a model for a national health care overhaul, advocates on various sides of the issue said the report underscores the urgency of including cost controls in any large-scale federal or state overhaul.

“While expanding coverage was the logical first step in Massachusetts, cost control is equally as important,’’ said Andrew Dreyfus, an executive vice president at Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts, the state’s largest private insurer with 3 million members. “And if you don’t face the cost issue directly, then you can jeopardize the progress you’ve made in expanding coverage.’’

President Obama has championed a national health care overhaul that includes cost controls, as well as coverage expansion to nearly every American. But critics have questioned some of his administration’s projected savings, and his proposal for a public insurance plan to compete with private insurers is faltering in Congress.

In Massachusetts, brokering the 2006 overhaul was such a delicate and years-long undertaking that the disparate interest groups - insurers, businesses, consumers, hospital and doctors organizations - all agreed to first tackle health coverage expansion and leave the cost question for a later date.

Now, the Commonwealth Fund report projects that without significant cost reforms, an annual family premium in Massachusetts will soar to $26,730 by 2020.

While Massachusetts residents face the highest premiums in the country, the costs do not eat as big a hole in the typical family budget as in most other states, the report said. That’s because household income in Massachusetts is much higher than the national average. For middle class families that make too much to qualify for state insurance subsidies, however, the premiums can be a significant burden.

One of the first steps to control costs was taken last year, when the Legislature passed a sweeping bill sponsored by Senate President Therese Murray, Democrat of Plymouth. Among other provisions, it restricted some payments and gifts to doctors from pharmaceutical and medical device companies and created a commission to recommend changes in how providers are paid.

Continued...



And what of the uninsured? There's a law on the books here that states no medical provider can turn away a patient in need, regardless of their ability to pay. (not all states have this; your mileage may vary.) Before RomneyCare, every provider in the Commonwealth paid a percentage of their profits to something called the "Free Care Pool", and in turn, when they had an uninsured patient, they could file a claim against the pool and get a partial payment for their services. RomneyCare assumes that everyone now has insurance, so the pool has been getting smaller and smaller every year since the law went into effect.

Unfortunately, the number of uninsured isn't decreasing at the same pace, so providers are still treating people who can't afford to pay. Only now, instead of having a state safety net so they can get at least minimal payments, there is none....so they end up eating those costs. It's not been widely reported in the media, but those of us in the business know that hospitals are bleeding money and many big name places in the city are on the verge of bankruptcy....and doctors in private practice (particularly General Practitioners, or your family doctor) are leaving the state in droves for greener pastures, or leaving the industry entirely because they can't make any money at it anymore.

Many in Washington are pointing to us and saying "see, it can be done!" But like our differently-winged friends keep telling us at the protests this year, 'Read the Bill' and see what the real cost of healthcare reform is in Massachusetts. It's not really working out.


 

13 comments (Latest Comment: 08/24/2009 09:09:47 by nucleart)
   Perma Link

Share This!

Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
Technorati

Add a Comment

Please login to add a comment...


Comments:

Order comments Newest to Oldest  Refresh Comments

Comment by trojanrabbit on 08/22/2009 13:38:41
Excellent post as always Tri.



Yeah, RomneyCare. Pay over 1K/month for crappy "health care"? No thanks. Still cheaper to pay the penalty & pray.



Oh and you're so lucky you got COBRA (actually I was as well at one time), because if you lose your job through your employer going bankrupt, you're SOL.



It was COBRA that helped us pay $###,### for 2 major cancer surgeries, but still its not like we weren't paying premium$ for the past 15-20 years.

Comment by trojanrabbit on 08/22/2009 13:45:45
For all the arm-waving wharrgarrbl we got yesterday from the "meteorologists" about possible tornadoes what happened at Chez Trojan?



Nothing really, the outdoor table got flipped over in some wind gusts (my fault for not taking the umbrella down). All the nice refreshing rain slid to the north. And instead of near-oppresive 74 degree dewpoints, it's now stands at a comfortable-i'm-gonna-go-out-and-run-a-mile-or-two 73.

Comment by trojanrabbit on 08/22/2009 14:09:42
Another hoot from World Nut Daily - Sean Hannity thinking of a Presidential run in 2012, if God directs him.



But don't bother to check WND - the site's been Farked.



FTFA



WASHINGTON - Talk-show host Sean Hannity, a vocal opponent of Barack Obama's policies, said today he would not rule out a bid

for the presidency in 2012.



Egged on by radio colleague Bill Cunningham, Hannity said he would consider entering the front lines of the political fray if God directs him.



"I've never made a decision in my life without - whatever destiny God has you've got to fulfill it," he said. "I'm not sure that's my destiny."



Hannity would make a formidable candidate, with the likability of Reagan, good looks and strong convictions. He's also a polished communicator and knows the issues inside out.



And he can debate.




I think I lost it after that last line and couldn't go on. Anyway, the full article is quoted in the Fark link.





I thought batshit-crazy Michelle Bachmann was being directed by God.

Comment by livingonli on 08/22/2009 16:47:23
Gee, Republicans are really good at Health Care Reform, aren't they?

Comment by trojanrabbit on 08/22/2009 16:51:47
Hi Liv!



Again, all the rain is passing by just to our west. Got a brief burst of rain that lasted for 2 minutes tops. All I did was unplug the laptop and threw the extension cord inside. Plugged it back in 10 minutes later.

Comment by livingonli on 08/22/2009 16:58:27
There was a nasty thunderstorm here last night when I went to bed. I got out of work at 2 AM last night and got home at 2:30 before it hit. It started coming down around 4 AM with the thunder and lightning. The sun was just out a moment ago but the clouds have come back. I'm supposed to be covering a live horse race from Saratoga at 5 PM and they could be getting soaked.

Comment by livingonli on 08/22/2009 17:06:50
Driving home last night, I had Coast to Coast AM on my XM unit. The show does have a strange ideology.

Comment by Mondobubba on 08/22/2009 17:34:11
Quote by livingonli:

Driving home last night, I had Coast to Coast AM on my XM unit. The show does have a strange ideology.




Liv, besides the "Chariots of the Gods" nonsense, what else?

Comment by Will in Chicago on 08/22/2009 17:35:43
Excellent post, TriSec!



I don't think mandating another expense for people who can't afford it makes sense. However, there are too many politicians who are bought and paid for by pharmaceutical and health care industry interests who view those companies as needing their protection.



In the end, I think it will be up to us to get a public option passed. In the end, change comes not from politicians and pundits, but the people.

Comment by Mondobubba on 08/22/2009 17:56:07
OMG, I don't know if this was intention, but on an ad for the Dugger Family trip to DC, a sign for C St!

Comment by livingonli on 08/22/2009 18:45:19
Quote by Mondobubba:

Quote by livingonli:

Driving home last night, I had Coast to Coast AM on my XM unit. The show does have a strange ideology.




Liv, besides the "Chariots of the Gods" nonsense, what else?


One caller was suggesting that TV is creating violence as a means of creating conditions where people would support gun control by creating the violent conditions where people would support gun control and then the police would take our guns away and create a police state. Don't ask me to explain the logic of that caller.

Comment by livingonli on 08/23/2009 03:56:57
Did mentioning Coast-to-Coast AM kill the blog?

Comment by nucleart on 08/24/2009 09:09:47
It's quite apparent this blog is for the knuckleheads to the far left or socialist pigs who have been suckered into thinking that Obamacare is perfect and that he has done no wrong to this country. G.W. Bush screwed this country up but Obama has added to it by leaps and bounds. This country was run by a bufoon for 8 years and now we are being run by a moron that thinks he's got the plan to put this country back on itss feet. Sorry comrades but i don't buy the B.S. you are trying to sell. I don't feel like paying for insurance for some illegal immigrant or some lazy slug that doesn't feel like he/she should have to work. If you have not figured it out i am neither Republican nor Democrat, i vote for who i feel is the best choice.