About Us
Mission Statement
Rules of Conduct
 
Name:
Pswd:
Remember Me
Register
 

The Faux Meme of Populism
Author: Raine    Date: 02/11/2010 13:42:52

Since the weekend of the Tea Party convention the media has been beating a slow drum, repeating the meme that this is a Populist movement. We've heard claims they are angry at the banks, angry at wall street and angry at government. That is pretty populist right? They have a small problem though -- it's not populist at all. If history does indeed repeat itself, this could be dangerous.

Last week, Peter Beinart, associate professor of politics and journalism wrote an article about this movement and populism. He writes:
A populist is someone who champions ordinary folks against the privileged few. For the original Populists—the people who created the Populist Party in the late 19th century—the ordinary folks were farmers and workers and the privileged few were bankers and railroad owners. The goal was to redistribute power from the latter to the former. The Populists wanted a currency based upon silver, not gold, which would make it cheaper for farmers to borrow and less profitable for bankers to lend. They wanted to nationalize the railroads, telegraphs and telephones so corporations couldn’t charge ordinary folks extortionate rates. They wanted a progressive income tax, an eight-hour workday, and laws making it easier to join labor unions, so workers would have greater protections and greater pay. And they wanted guaranteed pensions for sailors and soldiers, a kind of precursor to Social Security.

And what was the mechanism for this redistribution of power from the privileged few to ordinary folks? The mechanism was government. It was government that would coin silver, nationalize the railroads, and institute the income tax, pensions and the eight-hour shift. As the Populist Party declared in its first platform, in 1892, “We believe that the power of government—in other words, of the people—should be expanded…as rapidly and as far as the good sense of an intelligent people and the teachings of experience shall justify, to the end that oppression, injustice and poverty shall eventually cease in the land.”
Anger is not populism. Having a woman who was paid a $100,000 speaking fee to rile up the masses is not populist. The Tea Partiers are not only opposed to bailing out the banks, they are opposed to regulating them as well. They want less government 'interference' with regards to Wall Street. They are certainly against progressives taxes.

Populists wanted to empower people by making this a more democratic country. They wanted to use government to more equally distribute the wealth in the United States. Tea Partiers believe the opposite; they don't believe that government can do that, an instead are in favor of disempowering our government. IF they succeed, they are actually going to empower the monied interests they claim to rail against. That's quite the opposite of populism, and the opposite of what they think they are doing by being a member of the Tea Party.

So you see, once again the Media is misleading everyone into believing a false meme. It's time for the left to take back a political movement that has always been a progressive idea. It's time for people to start calling the media out on this.

If it's not populism, then what is it? Sadly, it's much closer to what happened in Italy
One view is that fascism in Italy was a response to the perceived failings of democracy, liberalism and Marxism, which were seen as either favouring individualism or internationalism at the expense of the nation. Fascism presented itself as a radical nationalist alternative to Bolshevism. It nevertheless incorporated aspects of Bolshevism, such as the single-party state, elite rule over the masses, and appeals to the proletariat. At a time when war veterans were facing unemployment and other economic problems, fascists promoted a form of collectivism, calling for the end of bourgeois individualism, as well as opposing Marxism for its anti-nationalism and perceived anti-patriotism. [...]

Disillusionment with liberalism deepened with the 1929 stock market crash and the Great Depression. Alfredo Rocco, Benito Mussolini and Giovanni Gentile justified fascism as answering a need for purpose in an absurd world.
I try not to use the word fascism, as it's very inflammatory during these political times, but I think in this case, it is warranted from a historical point of view. What is happening with the Tea Party movement may or may not be exactly the same as what happened in Italy, but there certainly are comparisons to be drawn. People are genuinely angry, and monied interests have seized upon that for their own personal gain.

It's easy to go after Sarah Palin, but the real problem isn't her, it's what people think she represents.

The problem is that whether they know it or not, people are being led down a path that is against their own self interests. The media is more than happy to help them along. That can become a very dangerous thing. History has shown us that time and time again.

It's simply not populism. Don't get fooled again.

and
Raine

 

24 comments (Latest Comment: 02/12/2010 01:07:04 by livingonli)
   Perma Link

Share This!

Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
Technorati

Add a Comment

Please login to add a comment...


Comments:

Order comments Newest to Oldest  Refresh Comments

Comment by BobR on 02/11/2010 13:57:39
excellent!



I think this phrase is key:

We believe that the power of government—in other words, of the people—should be expanded


Discussions often turn into an "us -vs- Big Government" meme, when government is truly "of the people, by the people"... unfortunately not always "for the people", especially when the Republicans are in charge.

Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2010 14:09:21
MOrning



Currently home - have a flat tire and we're waiting for roadside servie to come change it then on to buy a new tire - this has been a rather expensive winter for my poor little car - oh well, what am I to do expect try and roll with it.





I don't know that they general person would know what a real "populist" movement was if it came up and bit them on the ass

Comment by m-hadley on 02/11/2010 14:21:16
Great Post Raine - reminds of the unforgettable words of dubya "fool me once, uhhhhh, fool me twice - well, you can't get fooled again." - ugh! Does anybody miss him? Not me Rock on kids, and please stay warm!

Cheers,

mfaye

Comment by Scoopster on 02/11/2010 16:35:52
No sir, I don't miss him.

Comment by livingonli on 02/11/2010 16:40:54
Good morning everyone.



Not fun going home last night from work last night. First, the plows came in and forced me to dig out of my parking spot at work in order to leave and then I found my driveway was blocked and not dug out so I had to park across the street and hope that the plows don't dig me in again.



And now I hear Dallas is getting snow and it's expected that parts of Alabama and Mississippi will get snow as well.

Comment by Raine on 02/11/2010 16:54:44
Oof sounds like a hella night liv.





Comment by livingonli on 02/11/2010 16:55:10
Quiet here this morning. I guess everyone is digging out this morning from the latest crapfest.

Comment by livingonli on 02/11/2010 16:56:51
Quote by Raine:

Oof sounds like a hella night liv.





It was and considering how my night vision sucks. It's not fun trying to do this stuff when it's dark. At least the sun is out today. And I entertained the cat when I came home.

Comment by Scoopster on 02/11/2010 17:24:51
Comment by TriSec on 02/11/2010 17:40:07


Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2010 18:19:21
Made it to work!



Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2010 18:21:49
Quote by livingonli:

Good morning everyone.



Not fun going home last night from work last night. First, the plows came in and forced me to dig out of my parking spot at work in order to leave and then I found my driveway was blocked and not dug out so I had to park across the street and hope that the plows don't dig me in again.



And now I hear Dallas is getting snow and it's expected that parts of Alabama and Mississippi will get snow as well.






I was worried about you getting home last night - glad to hear you made it okay despite the non-stop digging.



According to our weather guys here that storm is just supposed to stay to the should (ie the Carolina's) there's gonna be a clipper on Monday that shouldn't be so bad though



Just be careful traveling tonight they roads are gonna get slippery

Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2010 18:41:05
Raine, since you and Bobber are going to be snowed in this weekend, with a mad glint in your eye brought on by cabin fever am I still up for tomorrow's blog? I'd still like to do it if it's okay with you.

Comment by Scoopster on 02/11/2010 18:56:44
Comment by Raine on 02/11/2010 19:11:00
Quote by Mondobubba:

Raine, since you and Bobber are going to be snowed in this weekend, with a mad glint in your eye brought on by cabin fever am I still up for tomorrow's blog? I'd still like to do it if it's okay with you.
Indeed you are! Bobber could use a good sleep in.



Thanks again Mondo!

Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2010 19:21:02
Quote by Raine:

Quote by Mondobubba:

Raine, since you and Bobber are going to be snowed in this weekend, with a mad glint in your eye brought on by cabin fever am I still up for tomorrow's blog? I'd still like to do it if it's okay with you.
Indeed you are! Bobber could use a good sleep in.



Thanks again Mondo!






You are welcome. I've changed my topic though in light of an event Tuesday in Dade County.



How is Bobber plague? Better? How are your aching shoulders, hips, back, knees, etc?

Comment by Mondobubba on 02/11/2010 19:21:48
Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2010 19:50:05
I feel so out of the loop - what happened in Dade COunty?

Comment by BobR on 02/11/2010 20:02:25


silly fools - don't they know that it's ATM cards the Bible was referring to?... or credit cards... or our SSN... or blah blah blah...

Comment by BobR on 02/11/2010 20:03:35
Quote by wickedpam:

I feel so out of the loop - what happened in Dade COunty?


an election

Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2010 20:14:26
Quote by BobR:

Quote by wickedpam:

I feel so out of the loop - what happened in Dade COunty?


an election






aahhh - I'm guessing it didn't go well?

Comment by BobR on 02/11/2010 22:08:36
Quote by wickedpam:

Quote by BobR:

Quote by wickedpam:

I feel so out of the loop - what happened in Dade COunty?


an election




aahhh - I'm guessing it didn't go well?


Based on comments in yesterday's blog, it went quite well for a friend of Mondo's

Comment by wickedpam on 02/11/2010 22:27:00
Quote by BobR:

Quote by wickedpam:

Quote by BobR:

Quote by wickedpam:

I feel so out of the loop - what happened in Dade COunty?


an election




aahhh - I'm guessing it didn't go well?


Based on comments in yesterday's blog, it went quite well for a friend of Mondo's






oh cool, glad I was wrong in my assumption

Comment by livingonli on 02/12/2010 01:07:04
Teabaggers upset that Marvel Comics turned them into supervillains.



I may have to catch up on Captain America again.