About Us
Mission Statement
Rules of Conduct
 
Name:
Pswd:
Remember Me
Register
 

What's elite?
Author: Raine    Date: 11/15/2010 13:55:15

I suppose you heard about this last week:
The draft proposal, penned by commission co-chairs Erskine Bowles and Alan Simpson, suggests a number of ways to cut discretionary spending by more than $200 billion in 2015 -- including reducing federal funding for the Smithsonian and the National Park Service. The commission co-chairs suggest the Smithsonian Institution should charge admission fees at its 19 museums and the National Zoo, which are all currently free, to make up for the lost funding.

If the Smithsonian's federal funding were cut by $225 million in 2015, it could make up for it by charging an average fee of $7.50 per visitor, they argue. Bowles and Simpson point out that several notable private museums in the United States charge anywhere from $10 to $20 per visitor, with lower rates for children and seniors, while zoos charge even more.
This is not just fiscally irresponsible. As it suggests cutting funding that is already there while increasing the fees, it is - in my opinion - morally unethical.

The purpose of the Smithsonian can be found in it's history:
In 1826, James Smithson, a British scientist, drew up his last will and testament, naming his nephew as beneficiary. Smithson stipulated that, should the nephew die without heirs (as he would in 1835), the estate should go “to the United States of America, to found at Washington, under the name of the Smithsonian Institution, an establishment for the increase and diffusion of knowledge among men.

The motives behind Smithson’s bequest remain mysterious. He never traveled to the United States and seems to have had no correspondence with anyone here. Some have suggested that his bequest was motivated in part by revenge against the rigidities of British society, which had denied Smithson, who was illegitimate, the right to use his father’s name. Others have suggested it reflected his interest in the Enlightenment ideals of democracy and universal education.
(Bold face mine)

I have a liberal bias for the arts and history. I believe that arts, science and history should be something that belongs to all Americans -- not just those who can afford it. The Smithsonian institution was given to ALL of Americans, including the poor. Aside from that, while it charges no entry fees, one should be aware we do pay for it in our tax dollars; we are already paying for a privilege afforded to everyone in this country and the world. This is what makes it different from a diversion like an amusement park. The institution is a showcase to the world bringing tourism from all countries. Tourism is an important sector for our economy -- the money not spent on museum admission is often spent in the businesses that surround it, such as restaurants and retail stores. Tourism also generates jobs. Free access is an investment in the future of the economic sector.

For myself, it goes to something larger. Why are we willing to put a cost on our national treasures? Why should only those that are affluent enough be allowed to view the collections inside it's walls? One could argue that there are many paid museums out there, but ask yourselves this: How many inner city children get the chance to have their eyes opened to the possibilities and the creativity given to us by people like Leonardo, Michaelangelo, Hopper, Freud, Edison? How many poor rural families who live off the land or paycheck to paycheck can see Van Gogh and Picasso? What happens when the poor among us are excluded from being able to experience this? The are cut of from the realm of possibility, and they are excluded from access to the same riches as those that have more in this nation.

This is what is so attractive about the Smithsonian institution: It is not exclusionary. You can be from the most elite private school in America or the toughest poorest school in Detroit and still have access to the same priceless collection of artifacts.

I am not a fan of admission to Museums, although I do understand the need for funding them. New York City has it's Metropolitan Musuem, and it suggests a 12 dollar fee.It also has membership levels that allow for more intimate access to functions held there, but the base line is that everyone, no matter how much money they have, can view the Temple of Dendur or any other priceless pieces of history. I submit that charging fees will further the divide between the upper and lower class. As always -- the lower the class is the one that will suffer. Only thru access, education and understanding can we give those that have less the chance to learn that they truly can aspire to be anything. We should be a nation that lifts people up and out of poverty, be it economic, educational or cultural. That is what art, science and history is supposed to do.

The Smithsonian institution was never supposed to exist as a cash cow. It was meant to be increase and diffuse knowledge among people. I wish more museums existed for that purpose. That purpose changed my world the first time I went to the Metropolitan in the 8th grade on a school trip. That was the only way it was going to happen, as we just didn't have the money or time as a family to consider a trip to the city. I was exposed to something that I never thought possible: that was that there was a purpose for my doodling and drawing, and that it had a place where it could be enjoyed by others. I might never have taken the course I charted to follow my passion as an artist if it were not for the ability to access a museum. This should be something everyone should have, not just the few that can afford it. That is the definition of elitist.

There are better ways to approach our debt problems than by taking away something that belongs to all of us. It will only make us poorer as a nation.

and

Raine
 

42 comments (Latest Comment: 11/15/2010 21:24:08 by livingonli)
   Perma Link

Share This!

Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
Technorati

Add a Comment

Please login to add a comment...


Comments:

Order comments Newest to Oldest  Refresh Comments

Comment by TriSec on 11/15/2010 14:14:04
Morning, comrades!

Near and dear to my heart, Raine. Yesterday morning, I took a handful of Cub Scouts to Cambridge, MA to tread upon the hallowed grounds of Harvard Yard. Our goal for the day was the Museum of Natural History...free to all citizens of this Commonwealth every Sunday before noon.

Boston's MFA has free admission on Wednesdays after 4pm (museum open late) and many other places around the city offer reduced or free admission at certain times of year.

Art and culture belong to us all.


Comment by TriSec on 11/15/2010 14:18:10
Oh, and on your last paragraph...

The Saugus Ironworks in my hometown was within walking distance of my elementary school. As a National Historical Site, it was and still is free to all. We walked down there a number of times a year for tours, and in conjunction with the Bicentennial, we did a large marionette show of a grade-school interpretation of the revolution, which was highly regarded by the local press. Our school also had a "militia" that marched in all the town parades, decked out in colonial garb.

Much like you, I attribute those experiences to kindling my somewhat obsessive interest in hunting down historical sites and making a point to stand on the same ground where something important happened.



Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 14:19:29
Morning

You know there are reasons why I don't go to the Spy Museum, the Newseum, the Holocust museum and others that charge money - a) I don't have the money and b)the middle man that sells (or at least used too)tickets to places like the Holocust museum. When it first opened Ticketron was only place you could get tickets and while the tickets themselves were free, Ticketron charged $1 service charge. I don't feel that a company should be making a profit on museums that are publicly financed.



Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 14:31:49
Also from the link at the Smithsonian site:
After eight years of sometimes heated debate, an Act of Congress signed by President James K. Polk on Aug. 10, 1846, established the Smithsonian Institution as a trust to be administered by a Board of Regents and a Secretary of the Smithsonian.


how do these proposed fees square up with a congressionally enacted Trust?

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 14:34:32
and what's with both Smithson and his nephew not having *heirs* ???? just curious about that one!

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 14:55:23
Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 15:01:47



I know something about zombies but what are "Starcraft" zombie is

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 15:07:54
Quote by wickedpam:



I know something about zombies but what are "Starcraft" zombie is

I was hoping you could have shed some light on that one as well....



Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 15:17:40
Quote by Raine:
Quote by wickedpam:



I know something about zombies but what are "Starcraft" zombie is

I was hoping you could have shed some light on that one as well....



googled - apparently its a video game zombie. Not playing starcraft I'm not sure if this is something significant since the only real zombie debates I know of are fast vs slow and zombie vs ninja


Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 15:46:02
oh yeah, forgot this the Westboro was protesting in Woodbridge this morning. One of the local churchs that I pass on the way to work, and the one that a lot of the school buses pass in the morning, has people on the road with signs like "God Loves Everyone" and so on I almost cried!

Woodbridge Counter Protest Dwarfs Westboro it is also from this morning

Comment by BobR on 11/15/2010 15:49:42
Quote by wickedpam:
Quote by Raine:
Quote by wickedpam:



I know something about zombies but what are "Starcraft" zombie is

I was hoping you could have shed some light on that one as well....



googled - apparently its a video game zombie. Not playing starcraft I'm not sure if this is something significant since the only real zombie debates I know of are fast vs slow and zombie vs ninja

okayyyyyy....



Comment by BobR on 11/15/2010 15:50:45
oh - and regarding the blog. If they start charging fees, they will soon realize this is like cutting open the goose to get to the golden eggs.

Comment by Scoopster on 11/15/2010 15:52:23
Morning all & Happy Mondee!

I can shed a little light on the "Starcraft Zombie" thing.. Yes, Starcraft and its newly-released sequel are very popular computer games. And in general, a "zombie" is a game addict. Now what does that have to do with South Korea? Well they tend to be more overly addicted to playing SC/SC2 as a nation than any other..

Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 15:55:09
Quote by Scoopster:
Morning all & Happy Mondee!

I can shed a little light on the "Starcraft Zombie" thing.. Yes, Starcraft and its newly-released sequel are very popular computer games. And in general, a "zombie" is a game addict. Now what does that have to do with South Korea? Well they tend to be more overly addicted to playing SC/SC2 as a nation than any other..



well that makes more sense

Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 16:02:41
ummm - no they send their money out of the country

Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 16:03:18
flat tax

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 16:03:27
I rewrote parts of todays blog and submitted it as an op-ed to the Post.

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 16:28:48
Quote by wickedpam:
Quote by Scoopster:
Morning all & Happy Mondee!

I can shed a little light on the "Starcraft Zombie" thing.. Yes, Starcraft and its newly-released sequel are very popular computer games. And in general, a "zombie" is a game addict. Now what does that have to do with South Korea? Well they tend to be more overly addicted to playing SC/SC2 as a nation than any other..



well that makes more sense
Sounds like a gamer came up with that map.


Comment by TriSec on 11/15/2010 16:29:12
Quote by BobR:
oh - and regarding the blog. If they start charging fees, they will soon realize this is like cutting open the goose to get to the golden eggs.


That's what I like the most about a DC vacation...it's cheap. I drive there, and all we need is a bed and meals; all the attractions are free.

If I have to pay for everything....well, Roger Williams Park zoo is an hour away, the local museums in Boston are on a par with some of the Smithsonian, and the New England Air Museum is near Hartford. Day trips, all.




Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 16:32:07
Quote by Raine:
I rewrote parts of todays blog and submitted it as an op-ed to the Post.


awesome!

Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 16:35:26
thank you Chris - I dont' get the loop holes the rich get - I mean hell their talking about doing away with the mortgage deduction, that will just asure that I never even think about buying another house

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 16:38:50
Quote by wickedpam:
Quote by Raine:
I rewrote parts of todays blog and submitted it as an op-ed to the Post.


awesome!

I felt it was an important part of the discussion that many have not seem to have made.

It isn't just that people don;t want to pay -- it is the reasons why they should not HAVE to pay.

Affluent folks have always had access to the arts, science and culture -- it is revolutionary to offer it to the "lower class" and it's what makes it very American -- we are a nation where we are taught that you can be anything -- the only way to realize that is to allow access to the knowledge that can get you there.



Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 16:43:13
Obese People Eat for Free at the Heart Attack Grill

And yes, this is as serious as a Heart Attack.

Comment by livingonli on 11/15/2010 16:44:52
Good morning all.

The GOP is more exposed between the flat tax, sales tax, and user fee schemes. As Leona Helmsley said, "only the little people pay taxes".

Comment by BobR on 11/15/2010 16:49:04
Quote by Raine:
Obese People Eat for Free at the Heart Attack Grill

And yes, this is as serious as a Heart Attack.

nasty

Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 16:55:16
Quote by Raine:
Obese People Eat for Free at the Heart Attack Grill

And yes, this is as serious as a Heart Attack.



freakin' enablers

Comment by livingonli on 11/15/2010 16:57:36
That stuff even makes me sick and I'm a pig.

Comment by Mondobubba on 11/15/2010 16:59:00


Two things. This map is hilarious. Australia is indeed Arkansas with a beach.

Being sick sucks ass! :kick:

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 18:06:35
Mala!

I missed this a few weeks ago, but since you were there for the taping....


Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 18:16:40
Quote by Raine:
Mala!

I missed this a few weeks ago, but since you were there for the taping....
Btw -- You can see Stan in the video


Comment by wickedpam on 11/15/2010 18:24:00
Just saw it on the book of faces XD



I love that everyone but you and the cowboy were so serious, you added the perfect hint of levity



had to laugh when I saw Stan in the background too

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 18:27:35
Quote by wickedpam:
Just saw it on the book of faces XD

I love that everyone but you and the cowboy were so serious, you added the perfect hint of levity

had to laugh when I saw Stan in the background too
I was really nervous to watch it.... and I actually laughed at myself, cause it was a bit funny.




Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 18:30:45
We don't just embrace insanity here,
We feel it up, french kiss it and buy it a drink...

That is what Bob said to me when we first met...

Comment by TriSec on 11/15/2010 19:38:04
Seems like I've been ahead of the curve all along. I quit flying in 2003. I hate being right like this.

Aviation is still dead to me.



Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 19:42:53
Quote by TriSec:
Seems like I've been ahead of the curve all along. I quit flying in 2003. I hate being right like this.

Aviation is still dead to me.

Just a serious question -- how is it that Israel can have what is probably the most secure airline in the world and not put there customers thru this garbage?


Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 19:46:04
Regarding El Al


Isaac Yeffet, the former head of security for El Al and now an aviation security consultant in New York, said El Al has prevented terrorism in the air by making sure every passenger is interviewed by a well-trained agent before check-in.


Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 19:52:15
here is some more About El Al from another site:
We were in the Budapest airport the morning after the Christmas Day terrorist attack, when TSA lost its mind and demanded that international airport officials do the same. It's a tiny terminal, but Hungarian security personnel were on in force. Passengers were being randomly questioned, semi-automatic weapons were prominently displayed, and bomb-sniffing dogs were making circuits around the seats every few minutes. There's nothing inherently wrong with that, but there was a very palpable feeling that no one knew exactly what they were supposed to be doing.

In contrast, El Al's people went through their normal morning routine. They cordoned off their corner of the airport, did their interviews the way they do every morning, and methodically moved people through the line. You could literally see the difference.


Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 19:58:14
A little part of me just died.


And a lot of respect for the New Oxford American Dictionary died as well.

Comment by Raine on 11/15/2010 20:27:22
Quote by Raine:
A little part of me just died.


And a lot of respect for the New Oxford American Dictionary died as well.
I'm thinking about this a little more. From the link:
refudiate: verb used loosely to mean "reject": she called on them to refudiate the proposal to build a mosque. 
[origin -- blend of refute and repudiate]


This is a person who misspoke, and after all -- we all do. For that I can even understand. That said

Here is the definition of Define from Merriam-Webster:
de·fine verb \di-ˈfīn\
transitive verb
1a : to determine or identify the essential qualities or meaning of
b : to discover and set forth the meaning of (as a word)
c : to create on a computer
2
a : to fix or mark the limits of : demarcate
b : to make distinct, clear, or detailed especially in outline

3: characterize, distinguish
You can't call something a word and say it is loosely defined and then call it the word of the year.

They are nothing more than the D-listed version of dictionaries to me at this point.





Comment by TriSec on 11/15/2010 20:29:42
Speaking of history, I didn't post this yesterday, but how bizarre is this?

Yesterday was both Leopold Mozart's and Johann Beethoven's birthday, albeit about 20 years apart.

Comment by livingonli on 11/15/2010 21:24:08
I feel like I need to sleep for a week.