About Us
Mission Statement
Rules of Conduct
 
Name:
Pswd:
Remember Me
Register
 

I Don't Know
Author: Raine    Date: 12/17/2012 13:41:30

Yesterday, Velveeta pointed us to this article. I strongly urge you to read the entire article. No mother, no father -- no family or loved ones should have to go through what she writes of. Sadly, and not surprisingly, here we are once again.

In kitchens and coffee shops across the country, we tearfully debate the many faces of violence in America: gun culture, media violence, lack of mental health services, overt and covert wars abroad, religion, politics and the way we raise our children. Liza Long, a writer based in Boise, says it’s easy to talk about guns. But it’s time to talk about mental illness. (...)

I live with a son who is mentally ill. I love my son. But he terrifies me.

A few weeks ago, Michael pulled a knife and threatened to kill me and then himself after I asked him to return his overdue library books. His 7 and 9 year old siblings knew the safety plan -- they ran to the car and locked the doors before I even asked them to. I managed to get the knife from Michael, then methodically collected all the sharp objects in the house into a single Tupperware container that now travels with me. Through it all, he continued to scream insults at me and threaten to kill or hurt me.

That conflict ended with three burly police officers and a paramedic wrestling my son onto a gurney for an expensive ambulance ride to the local emergency room. The mental hospital didn’t have any beds that day, and Michael calmed down nicely in the ER, so they sent us home with a prescription for Zyprexa and a follow-up visit with a local pediatric psychiatrist. (...)

When I asked my son’s social worker about my options, he said that the only thing I could do was to get Michael charged with a crime. “If he’s back in the system, they’ll create a paper trail,” he said. “That’s the only way you’re ever going to get anything done. No one will pay attention to you unless you’ve got charges.”

I don’t believe my son belongs in jail. The chaotic environment exacerbates Michael’s sensitivity to sensory stimuli and doesn’t deal with the underlying pathology. But it seems like the United States is using prison as the solution of choice for mentally ill people. According to Human Rights Watch, the number of mentally ill inmates in U.S. prisons quadrupled from 2000 to 2006, and it continues to rise -- in fact, the rate of inmate mental illness is five times greater (56 percent) than in the non-incarcerated population.
It's a horrible situation, compounded by something else even more horrific: Ms. Long lives in Idaho.

Idaho has no insanity defense.

Last month the Supreme court decided not to hear a case challenging the states lack of one.
It took months of medication and treatment for Loughner to understand the charges against him. That comes as no surprise, given the disturbed-looking photos of him after the crime. And the country got a similar view of violence and untreated mental illness in James Holmes, the 24-year-old who shot up a movie theater in Aurora, Colo., in July. Both Loughner and Holmes spiraled out of control while enrolled at a university yet fell through the holes of the health care net that should have caught them. This is a story we’ve been hearing since at least the 2007 mass killing by a student at Virginia Tech.

The mental illness of criminal defendants, however, is not of current interest to the Supreme Court. This week, the justices turned down a case challenging Idaho’s complete lack of an insanity defense. In Idaho, “mental condition” is not a defense to any charge of criminal conduct. In the case the Supreme Court won’t hear, John Joseph Delling, a paranoid schizophrenic, shot and killed two of his friends and wounded a third while seized by the delusion that he was a “type of Jesus” and that his friends were “taking his energy” in a way that would kill him. A psychologist testified that he truly—and delusionally and tragically—believed he had to stop his friends to save his own life.

Delling, like Loughner, had to be medicated for a year before he could be found competent to stand trial. At that point, the judge found that when he committed the killings, he was unable to appreciate the wrongfulness of his actions. But Delling was still guilty of murder, because there was no insanity defense for him to plead. Think about that for a minute: The state was saying that a man who was so insane that he could not understand that it was wrong to kill two of his friends was just as culpable as a sane person.
In 2006, the Supreme court made it easier for states to be a little bit more mean-spirited about the insanity defense, The Model Penal Code as defined by the American Law institute is "A person is not responsible for criminal conduct if at the time of such conduct as a result of mental disease or defect he lacks substantial capacity either to appreciate the criminality of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the requirements of the law." in 2006, Arizona, Delaware, Georgia, Louisiana, and Ohio all block defendants from using this defense.

James Holmes, Jared Loughner and John Joeseph Delling all will go away for life. Two of those three we know have been medicated well enough to finally understand what they did. By the time the risk factors had metastasized into violent tendencies, IT WAS TOO LATE -- Too late for them and too late for their victims. It is too late for those killed in Newtown, Connecticut on Friday. We still don't know what happened there, but I am going to go out on a limb and say that a young man - barely at that - killing his mother, teachers educators and 20 babies had something happen in his mind.

Mental illness should not be treated as a crime. The time to treat it is before a person that is sick spirals so out of control. We need to as a nation provide for better access to mental health care. It needs to be taken as seriously as cancer. We need to stop treating it as a stigma and a human defect or flaw. It's an illness. Too many lives are lost to death or to a prison system that is not capable of helping our sick.
I have to point out that it’s very rare for mentally ill people to become deranged killers. According to the Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law, studies show that having a mental illness in itself doesn’t increase the likelihood of becoming seriously violent. Untreated mental illness, however, is a risk factor. And so it is terribly scary, as well as terribly sad, that “America’s mental health care system is horribly broken and horribly underfunded,” as Robert Bernstein, director of the Bazelon Center, underscored after the Arizona shootings.

Serious mental illness can be incredibly hard to live with and to deal with. But these shootings keep telling us that we sweep it under the rug at our own peril. After a massacre like Aurora, it’s very hard to see the killer as worthy of any sort of sympathy. "They keep talking about fairness for him," a man whose sister died in the Aurora shootings told the Associated Press at Holmes’ court appearance this week. "It's like they're babying this dude." It’s an understandable reaction, but if Holmes’ lawyers are right and he is seriously ill, he won’t be coddled by the legal system. He’ll get the treatment he needed, but far too late.

We do have a serious Gun problem in this nation. The flaws of our gun culture are magnified by the gaping hole that is the untreated human beings in our nation. Velveeta asked Why? yesterday. She pointed out that there are a small number of people in our nation that prey on the fears of our citizens. Their number are small, but they are loud and vocal and people believe what they say. On Saturday, BobR wondered about the romanticizing of guns in our culture
Even worse, once again those who support gun rights over everything else are saying that teachers should be armed, or at least there should be armed guards at every school. To what end? Following this to its logical conclusion, it would mean armed guards on every street corner. Our country will become a prison, and we the inmates. The 2nd Amendment was originally proposed as a hedge against hegemony within our borders. It's ironic, then, that those who consider that amendment to be the most important are proposing a solution which contradicts it's intent. In an effort to protect a "right" that ostensibly prevents a police state, they are proposing a scenario which is exactly that.

Why? Today my answer is: I don't know.

More prisons and more guns is simply not the solution. Time after time again we have been shown this. We must not accept our insanity as something that is hopeless and untreatable. We must deal with it. Anything less is truly insane.

and
Raine
 

100 comments (Latest Comment: 12/18/2012 00:44:24 by TriSec)
   Perma Link

Share This!

Furl it!
Spurl
NewsVine
Reddit
Technorati

Add a Comment

Please login to add a comment...


Comments:

Order comments Newest to Oldest  Refresh Comments

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 13:55:15
Maybe it is time we started staving the prison-industrial complex?

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 13:58:54
Take some of those millions of dollars that go to private prisons and put them into mental health services? Stopping the drug war would be a good place to get money out of the prison-industrial complex.

Comment by TriSec on 12/17/2012 13:59:36
Morning, comrades.

I read the story yesterday. My limited experience with youth in this situation is primarily with already diagnosed and over-medicated kids at the Scout meeting. It's actually quite a sad thing....we try to work with the scouts and the parents as best as we can, but that's not really our world. Maybe it should be...every little bit helps, I guess.

But I've never had anyone as violent as this story. I did have one scout that was not medicated - and his father was a "hands-off" type, made for interesting meetings, that's for sure. (We had more issues with Dad than his son - they eventually left the program, alas.)


Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 13:59:37
Quote by Mondobubba:
Take some of those millions of dollars that go to private prisons and put them into mental health services? Stopping the drug war would be a good place to get money out of the prison-industrial complex.
Agreed.




Comment by TriSec on 12/17/2012 14:01:29
Well, the Freakin' Sainted Raygun and his "War on Drugs".....chalk up another failure to the conservatives.

What is it with our opposites? Why do they have no common sense? This is probably the biggest problem - we can't even talk about these things without someboby going all batshit-crazy about it.



Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 14:01:57
Maybe we can stop calling everything a war?

War on Drugs...
War on Poverty...
War on Terror...
War on Women...
War on (insert war here)

We make everything sound so violent in this country-- it has become part of our Psyche.

Comment by wickedpam on 12/17/2012 14:03:39
Morning

Comment by BobR on 12/17/2012 14:07:27
Quote by Raine:
Maybe we can stop calling everything a war?

War on Drugs...
War on Poverty...
War on Terror...
War on Women...
War on (insert war here)

We make everything sound so violent in this country-- it has become part of our Psyche.

Once you call it a war, there's no getting out of it without someone being declared a winner and someone a loser. If we stop the "war on drugs", then the drug dealers win, see?

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 14:08:41
The students at my niece' school today we greeted with a State Troopers, A statie an airforce marshall and Town Police officer.

I am assuming that this is there way to provide support to the students?

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 14:09:45
Quote by BobR:
Quote by Raine:
Maybe we can stop calling everything a war?

War on Drugs...
War on Poverty...
War on Terror...
War on Women...
War on (insert war here)

We make everything sound so violent in this country-- it has become part of our Psyche.

Once you call it a war, there's no getting out of it without someone being declared a winner and someone a loser. If we stop the "war on drugs", then the drug dealers win, see?


Winners and losers: The American way of thinking. *sigh*


Comment by TriSec on 12/17/2012 14:10:21
Quote by Raine:
The students at my niece' school today we greeted with a State Troopers, A statie an airforce marshall and Town Police officer.

I am assuming that this is there way to provide support to the students?


That seems more intimidating to me - BE AFRAID, KIDS!



Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 14:10:21
Quote by TriSec:
Well, the Freakin' Sainted Raygun and his "War on Drugs".....chalk up another failure to the conservatives.

What is it with our opposites? Why do they have no common sense? This is probably the biggest problem - we can't even talk about these things without someboby going all batshit-crazy about it.



The War on Drugs started under Nixon, dude.


Comment by wickedpam on 12/17/2012 14:22:24
I've been wondering something since Friday - Australia is a younger nation then ours, they have a similar relationship with guns as American's do, they are still in a lot of cases a frontier nation. Why is it that they could enact a strict gun law in 1996/97 to banned semi-auto and automatic weapons after the Tasmania massacre but we here still him and haw over it years after Columbine?

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 14:24:12
I've said this before and I will say it again. If you want to understand the corrosive effects that the 40-year long War On Drugs has had on America's cities, watch "The Wire."

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 14:25:18
Quote by TriSec:
Quote by Raine:
The students at my niece' school today we greeted with a State Troopers, A statie an airforce marshall and Town Police officer.

I am assuming that this is there way to provide support to the students?


That seems more intimidating to me - BE AFRAID, KIDS!

That was my thought as well. Her School issued a statement over the weekend:

The news surrounding the tragic shootings at the Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut earlier today is shocking. Please join me in keeping the victims and their families in our thoughts and prayers. These violent acts are becoming way too common in our society and we must find a way to stop them from happening.

Children are very sensitive to adult reactions when these types of incidents occur. My experience is that adults should approach discussing school violence in an age-appropriate way with their children. It is important that children are encouraged (not compelled) to express concerns they may have. It is also important for children to be reminded that we spend significant time and energy keeping our schools among the safest of places to be.

The (ommitted) School District has a variety of resources available to support our students and their families in difficult times. Please contact my office if you need any assistance.
So I was surprised to read that such a show of force was at her high school today. There HAS to be better resources available.






Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 14:30:47
Quote by TriSec:
Quote by Raine:
The students at my niece' school today we greeted with a State Troopers, A statie an airforce marshall and Town Police officer.

I am assuming that this is there way to provide support to the students?


That seems more intimidating to me - BE AFRAID, KIDS!




You are hitting on big topic with me, Tri; The Fear. This virus has infected this country. Fear of Muslims, fear of terrorist, fear of strangers, fear of vaccines. The boundless capacity for unsubstantiated fear over the most trivial thing.

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 14:36:10
The show is talking about the story of Ms Long right now.

Comment by TriSec on 12/17/2012 14:39:02
Quote by Mondobubba:



You are hitting on big topic with me, Tri; The Fear. This virus has infected this country. Fear of Muslims, fear of terrorist, fear of strangers, fear of vaccines. The boundless capacity for unsubstantiated fear over the most trivial thing.



That's where I've got nothing; I see it too. "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself."

It's how to break the cycle that becomes the troubling thing. Maybe FDR was able to do it, no matter how briefly. (The Battle of Los Angeles notwithstanding). President Obama has some big shoes to fill.

And in a side note, this is why I remain a "Closeted Muslim" at the moment.


Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 14:40:47
This is stunning, just stunning.
Magazines that fed bullets into the primary firearm used to kill 26 children and adults at a Connecticut school would have been banned under state legislation that the National Rifle Association and gunmakers successfully fought.

The shooter at Sandy Hook Elementary in Newtown, Adam Lanza, 20, used a Bushmaster AR-15 rifle with magazines containing 30 rounds as his main weapon, said Connecticut State Police Lieutenant Paul Vance at a news conference yesterday.

A proposal in March 2011 would have made it a felony to possess magazines with more than 10 bullets and required owners to surrender them to law enforcement or remove them from the state. Opponents sent more than 30,000 e-mails and letters to state lawmakers as part of a campaign organized by the NRA and other gun advocates, said Robert Crook, head of the Hartford- based Coalition of Connecticut Sportsmen, which opposed the legislation.

“The legislators got swamped by NRA emails,” said Betty Gallo, who lobbied on behalf of the legislation for Southport- based Connecticut Against Gun Violence. “They were scared of the NRA and the political backlash.”


Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 14:52:14
Quote by TriSec:
Quote by Mondobubba:



You are hitting on big topic with me, Tri; The Fear. This virus has infected this country. Fear of Muslims, fear of terrorist, fear of strangers, fear of vaccines. The boundless capacity for unsubstantiated fear over the most trivial thing.



That's where I've got nothing; I see it too. "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself."

It's how to break the cycle that becomes the troubling thing. Maybe FDR was able to do it, no matter how briefly. (The Battle of Los Angeles notwithstanding). President Obama has some big shoes to fill.

And in a side note, this is why I remain a "Closeted Muslim" at the moment.



I feel that is whipped up by the media doing a poor job of reporting. There was a report on NPR about thimisol. Despite the ton of evidence that states otherwise they were still talking to some person who insists that it is the cause of autism.

Comment by TriSec on 12/17/2012 14:57:57
Ya know, I"m starting to think the only way things might change are if a gunman gets into the Capitol or a state legislature with a high-capacity magazine and has his way.



Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 15:03:36
Quote by TriSec:
Ya know, I"m starting to think the only way things might change are if a gunman gets into the Capitol or a state legislature with a high-capacity magazine and has his way.

Feinstein is introducing an assault weapons ban in the senate
That's a start.

But when it's countered with articles like this, from September we keep cuttingfunding for mental health care.



Comment by wickedpam on 12/17/2012 15:04:05
Quote by TriSec:
Ya know, I"m starting to think the only way things might change are if a gunman gets into the Capitol or a state legislature with a high-capacity magazine and has his way.



it wasn't a high-capacity clip but there was an incident in 1998 on Capitol Hill

Comment by Scoopster on 12/17/2012 15:07:28
Mornin' all...

The absolute bullheadedness of some of the people in this country about regulating the manufacture & sale of guns, and about properly identifying & treating the mental health issues that lead to such violence, is absolutely astounding. Even in the wake of this.. inexcusable and totally preventable slaughter, they continue to cry FROM MY COLD DEAD HANDS like Charlton Heston did years ago.

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 15:23:19
These words suddenly seem prescient:

You go into these small towns in Pennsylvania and, like a lot of small towns in the Midwest, the jobs have been gone now for 25 years and nothing's replaced them. And they fell through the Clinton administration, and the Bush administration, and each successive administration has said that somehow these communities are gonna regenerate and they have not.

And it's not surprising then they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy toward people who aren't like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.


Want to change things in America? Give them reasons to feel secure, give them jobs, give them health care -- give them a reason not to fear getting sick.

Give them reason not to fear.

What Obama said April 2008 may have been controversial, but he was right.

In order to see that change, it needs to not solely be the government, we need to be that change as well.




Comment by TriSec on 12/17/2012 15:46:39
Ya know, even in my darkest days of unemployment, when the larder was empty, and cable was going to be cut off tomorrow, and I only had $10 in savings.....I never thought I should go buy a gun and shoot stuff up.

Despair is real and relevant, but is it a motivator? Maybe I've just got my head screwed on better. (At least until Chemo messed up the threads.)



Comment by Will in Chicago on 12/17/2012 15:48:24
Good morning, bloggers!! Raine, thanks for a great if depressing blog.

There have been a few under reported incidents. First, going down to Alabama there were two incidents this weekend.

From Alabama.com
St. Vincent's Hospital operational after early morning shooting (gallery and video)
By Mia Watkins | mwatkins@al.com
on December 15, 2012

St. Vincent's Hospital is operational following an early morning shooting leaving one person dead and three more, including a Birmingham Police officer, injured.

"The situation is under control and the hospital is secure and stable," said Liz Moore, Vice President of Marketing and Communications. "There are no interruptions to any patient care services at this time."

According to Sgt. Johnny Williams, public information officer for the Birmingham Police Department, officers received a call from within the hospital at approximately 4 a.m. Two officers who patrol the South precinct responded to a gunman on the fifth floor. The officers arrived through two different corridors.

The suspect used a handgun and motive for the shooting is unclear at this time, said Williams.

"They engaged the suspect as they exited the elevator," he said. "The suspect opened fire on the officer. He wounded that officer and two other employees here at the hospital. The second responding officers returned gunfire, fatally wounding the suspect."


Reuters also reported on another incident in Alabama:

Man with assault rifle shot dead by police after Alabama triple murder

(Reuters) - A man armed with an assault-style rifle and suspected of killing three men in a domestic dispute was shot dead by police after a car chase and shootout that left an officer wounded, marking a second incident of deadly gun violence in Alabama in two days, officials said on Sunday.

The two shootings on Saturday in Alabama came a day after 20 children and six adults were shot to death by a gunman who went on a rampage with a military-style rifle at an elementary school in Newtown, Connecticut and then killed himself.

In Alabama, a gunman identified as Romero Roberto Moya, 33, was shot multiple times by police in the town of Oxford, east of Birmingham, as he stepped from a hijacked car that struck another vehicle on Saturday, police said.

A short distance away before he was killed, Moya had exchanged gunfire with other police after crashing his initial getaway car, leaving one officer critically injured, Oxford police Lieutenant L.G. Owens said.

The pursuit was triggered by a triple slaying Moya was suspected of committing at a trailer home earlier in the morning in Cleburne County, Alabama, near the Georgia state line, Owens said.



Closer to home and just a few towns from me, a man threatened to attack his wife's grade school. Here is the story from the Times of Northwest Indiana:

Police: Cedar Lake man wanted to kill 'as many people as he could' at elementary school

Diane Poulton Times Correspondent

CEDAR LAKE | While the tragic slaughter of children was unfolding at a Connecticut school Friday, Cedar Lake police and the Lake County Sheriff’s Department were busy dealing with reports a man threatening to kill "as many people as he could" at Jane Ball Elementary School.

Interim Cedar Lake Police Chief Gerald A. Smith said his officers were called to the home of Von I. Meyer, 60, in the 9300 block of West 133rd Avenue on Friday morning.

Smith said Meyer allegedly threatened to set his wife on fire after she fell asleep.

A police statement says Meyer also said he would enter Jane Ball Elementary School and "kill as many people as he could" before police could possible stop him.

Meyer’s home is located within 1,000 feet of the school and connected through a set of trails and walking paths, Smith said. Inside his home, authorities said they found 47 guns and ammunition worth more than $100,000.


Comment by wickedpam on 12/17/2012 15:51:17
ugh - the comment's in Channel 9's FB post about the NRA taking down their FB page is just sickening. People are now saying is someone didn't have a gun they would have a bomb like McViegh.


what the fuck is wrong with people

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 15:54:03
For what it is worth, I saw Lincoln yesterday. It is excellent. Well written, extremely well acted, Daniel Day Lewis is mesmerizing in the title role. Sally Fields is excellent as Crazy Mary Todd Lincoln and Tommy Lee Jones is great as Thaddeus Stevens. Hey Oscars, if they don't win for best actor, best actress and best supporting actors there will a problem.

Comment by Will in Chicago on 12/17/2012 15:54:06
I posted the following on my Facebook page yesterday. Here is something Ezra Klein of the Washington Post learned:

Mythbusting: Israel and Switzerland are not gun-toting utopias

My post “12 facts about guns and mass shootings” included a mention of Israel and Switzerland, societies where guns are reputed to be widely available, but where gun violence is rare. Janet Rosenbaum, an assistant professor of epidemiology at the School of Public Health at the State University of New York (SUNY) Downstate Medical Center School, has actually researched this question, and she wrote to tell me I had it wrong. We spoke shortly thereafter on the phone. A lightly edited transcript of our conversation follows.


Ezra Klein: Israel and Switzerland are often mentioned as countries that prove that high rates of gun ownership don’t necessarily lead to high rates of gun crime. In fact, I wrote that on Friday. But you say your research shows that’s not true.

Janet Rosenbaum: First of all, because they don’t have high levels of gun ownership. The gun ownership in Israel and Switzerland has decreased.

For instance, in Israel, they’re very limited in who is able to own a gun. There are only a few tens of thousands of legal guns in Israel, and the only people allowed to own them legally live in the settlements, do business in the settlements, or are in professions at risk of violence.

Both countries require you to have a reason to have a gun. There isn’t this idea that you have a right to a gun. You need a reason. And then you need to go back to the permitting authority every six months or so to assure them the reason is still valid.

The second thing is that there’s this widespread misunderstanding that Israel and Switzerland promote gun ownership. They don’t. Ten years ago, when Israel had the outbreak of violence, there was an expansion of gun ownership, but only to people above a certain rank in the military. There was no sense that having ordinary citizens [carry guns] would make anything safer.

Switzerland has also been moving away from having widespread guns. The laws are done canton by canton, which is like a province. Everyone in Switzerland serves in the army, and the cantons used to let you have the guns at home. They’ve been moving to keeping the guns in depots. That means they’re not in the household, which makes sense because the literature shows us that if the gun is in the household, the risk goes up for everyone in the household.


Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 15:54:20
Quote by wickedpam:
ugh - the comment's in Channel 9's FB post about the NRA taking down their FB page is just sickening. People are now saying is someone didn't have a gun they would have a bomb like McViegh.


what the fuck is wrong with people
You know what happened after the Oklahoma City bombing?

--------- they regulated the sale of fertilizer.

People are sick.


Comment by wickedpam on 12/17/2012 15:56:53
Quote by Raine:
Quote by wickedpam:
ugh - the comment's in Channel 9's FB post about the NRA taking down their FB page is just sickening. People are now saying is someone didn't have a gun they would have a bomb like McViegh.


what the fuck is wrong with people
You know what happened after the Oklahoma City bombing?

--------- they regulated the sale of fertilizer.

People are sick.



exactly


I just can't take people today.

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 16:02:14
Quote by Will in Chicago:
I posted the following on my Facebook page yesterday. Here is something Ezra Klein of the Washington Post learned:

Mythbusting: Israel and Switzerland are not gun-toting utopias

Posted by Ezra Klein on December 14, 2012

My post “12 facts about guns and mass shootings” included a mention of Israel and Switzerland, societies where guns are reputed to be widely available, but where gun violence is rare. Janet Rosenbaum, an assistant professor of epidemiology at the School of Public Health at the State University of New York (SUNY) Downstate Medical Center School, has actually researched this question, and she wrote to tell me I had it wrong. We spoke shortly thereafter on the phone. A lightly edited transcript of our conversation follows.

Ricky Carioti — The Washington Post

Ezra Klein: Israel and Switzerland are often mentioned as countries that prove that high rates of gun ownership don’t necessarily lead to high rates of gun crime. In fact, I wrote that on Friday. But you say your research shows that’s not true.

Janet Rosenbaum: First of all, because they don’t have high levels of gun ownership. The gun ownership in Israel and Switzerland has decreased.

For instance, in Israel, they’re very limited in who is able to own a gun. There are only a few tens of thousands of legal guns in Israel, and the only people allowed to own them legally live in the settlements, do business in the settlements, or are in professions at risk of violence.

Both countries require you to have a reason to have a gun. There isn’t this idea that you have a right to a gun. You need a reason. And then you need to go back to the permitting authority every six months or so to assure them the reason is still valid.

The second thing is that there’s this widespread misunderstanding that Israel and Switzerland promote gun ownership. They don’t. Ten years ago, when Israel had the outbreak of violence, there was an expansion of gun ownership, but only to people above a certain rank in the military. There was no sense that having ordinary citizens [carry guns] would make anything safer.

Switzerland has also been moving away from having widespread guns. The laws are done canton by canton, which is like a province. Everyone in Switzerland serves in the army, and the cantons used to let you have the guns at home. They’ve been moving to keeping the guns in depots. That means they’re not in the household, which makes sense because the literature shows us that if the gun is in the household, the risk goes up for everyone in the household.


Despite evidence to the contrary, the gun lovers aren't going to believe this. Just like they think there are hordes of Canadians taking buses to the Mayo Clinic because Canada's health care system is such a mess.


Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 16:17:18
Quote by Raine:
Quote by wickedpam:
ugh - the comment's in Channel 9's FB post about the NRA taking down their FB page is just sickening. People are now saying is someone didn't have a gun they would have a bomb like McViegh.


what the fuck is wrong with people
You know what happened after the Oklahoma City bombing?

--------- they regulated the sale of fertilizer.

People are sick.



If I may quote Nick Cave. "People Ain't No Good." Yeah I feel that way today.

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 16:30:18
Caller, take you military service and your love of guns and pound sand. Rwanda is a BAD example to advocate for the use of semi automatic assault weapons.

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 16:37:10
Quote by Raine:
Caller, take you military service and your love of guns and pound sand. Rwanda is a BAD example to advocate for the use of semi automatic assault weapons.



Huh? Is he saying if the Hutus (or Tutsis, I get them confused) had assault rifles they wouldn't have had their limbs or heads hacked off with machetes?

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 16:37:51
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Raine:
Caller, take you military service and your love of guns and pound sand. Rwanda is a BAD example to advocate for the use of semi automatic assault weapons.



Huh? Is he saying if the Hutus (or Tutsis, I get them confused) had assault rifles they wouldn't have had their limbs or heads hacked off with machetes?
He was trying to go there. Miller was able to walk him back.




Comment by TriSec on 12/17/2012 16:38:01


So, does this mean that Mr. Huckabee will be standing with the Westboro Baptist Church at the anti-gay protests?


Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 16:38:32
:Makes not to self, call Louie Gomert's office and ask if he is crazy or just stump stupid:

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 16:39:05
Quote by Raine:
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Raine:
Caller, take you military service and your love of guns and pound sand. Rwanda is a BAD example to advocate for the use of semi automatic assault weapons.



Huh? Is he saying if the Hutus (or Tutsis, I get them confused) had assault rifles they wouldn't have had their limbs or heads hacked off with machetes?
He was trying to go there. Miller was able to walk him back.




Troll. Did he say he was a Marine?

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 16:42:56
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Raine:
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Raine:
Caller, take you military service and your love of guns and pound sand. Rwanda is a BAD example to advocate for the use of semi automatic assault weapons.



Huh? Is he saying if the Hutus (or Tutsis, I get them confused) had assault rifles they wouldn't have had their limbs or heads hacked off with machetes?
He was trying to go there. Miller was able to walk him back.




Troll. Did he say he was a Marine?
He just said he served-- in south America and stuff.



Comment by Will in Chicago on 12/17/2012 16:43:32
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Will in Chicago:
I posted the following on my Facebook page yesterday. Here is something Ezra Klein of the Washington Post learned:

Mythbusting: Israel and Switzerland are not gun-toting utopias

Posted by Ezra Klein on December 14, 2012

My post “12 facts about guns and mass shootings” included a mention of Israel and Switzerland, societies where guns are reputed to be widely available, but where gun violence is rare. Janet Rosenbaum, an assistant professor of epidemiology at the School of Public Health at the State University of New York (SUNY) Downstate Medical Center School, has actually researched this question, and she wrote to tell me I had it wrong. We spoke shortly thereafter on the phone. A lightly edited transcript of our conversation follows.

Ricky Carioti — The Washington Post

Ezra Klein: Israel and Switzerland are often mentioned as countries that prove that high rates of gun ownership don’t necessarily lead to high rates of gun crime. In fact, I wrote that on Friday. But you say your research shows that’s not true.

Janet Rosenbaum: First of all, because they don’t have high levels of gun ownership. The gun ownership in Israel and Switzerland has decreased.

For instance, in Israel, they’re very limited in who is able to own a gun. There are only a few tens of thousands of legal guns in Israel, and the only people allowed to own them legally live in the settlements, do business in the settlements, or are in professions at risk of violence.

Both countries require you to have a reason to have a gun. There isn’t this idea that you have a right to a gun. You need a reason. And then you need to go back to the permitting authority every six months or so to assure them the reason is still valid.

The second thing is that there’s this widespread misunderstanding that Israel and Switzerland promote gun ownership. They don’t. Ten years ago, when Israel had the outbreak of violence, there was an expansion of gun ownership, but only to people above a certain rank in the military. There was no sense that having ordinary citizens [carry guns] would make anything safer.

Switzerland has also been moving away from having widespread guns. The laws are done canton by canton, which is like a province. Everyone in Switzerland serves in the army, and the cantons used to let you have the guns at home. They’ve been moving to keeping the guns in depots. That means they’re not in the household, which makes sense because the literature shows us that if the gun is in the household, the risk goes up for everyone in the household.


Despite evidence to the contrary, the gun lovers aren't going to believe this. Just like they think there are hordes of Canadians taking buses to the Mayo Clinic because Canada's health care system is such a mess.



Some, I fear, would not listen to a choir of angels and a burning bush. Some people are so heavily invested in a world view as to be impervious to facts, no matter who presents it.


Comment by Will in Chicago on 12/17/2012 16:45:55
Nicole Sandler will be in for Randi Rhodes through the end of the year.


Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 16:48:26
Quote by Raine:
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Raine:
Quote by Mondobubba:
Quote by Raine:
Caller, take you military service and your love of guns and pound sand. Rwanda is a BAD example to advocate for the use of semi automatic assault weapons.



Huh? Is he saying if the Hutus (or Tutsis, I get them confused) had assault rifles they wouldn't have had their limbs or heads hacked off with machetes?
He was trying to go there. Miller was able to walk him back.




Troll. Did he say he was a Marine?
He just said he served-- in south America and stuff.



Interesting the right wing troll usually say they are Marines. Like being a Marine makes them extra special bad ass.


Comment by livingonli on 12/17/2012 16:50:45
Good morning, folks. The interesting thing is now I have gone back to the point of "Bowling for Columbine" which really showed how Americans (especially those who want to be heavily armed) are so afraid of everything and feel they need to be heavily armed should any of those fears come true. I still remember when Michael Moore asked the one gun nut who said he was stocking up if the government became tyrannical about Gandhi and he was completely clueless since he never heard of Gandhi and how he freed India without firing a shot.

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 16:51:10
So, who with me in calling Gohmert's office and asking if he's nuts or just stump stupid? Or both? It'll be fun!

Comment by Raine on 12/17/2012 17:01:32
Quote by Mondobubba:
So, who with me in calling Gohmert's office and asking if he's nuts or just stump stupid? Or both? It'll be fun!

I've not the time. I've already written a letter to my congress critter for another reason that has me perturbed. This is why.

I am saddened by his response, especially after seeing Jovan Belcher kill the mother of his child with a gun.

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 17:19:03
Quote by Raine:
Quote by Mondobubba:
So, who with me in calling Gohmert's office and asking if he's nuts or just stump stupid? Or both? It'll be fun!

I've not the time. I've already written a letter to my congress critter for another reason that has me perturbed. This is why.

I am saddened by his response, especially after seeing Jovan Belcher kill the mother of his child with a gun.



Yeah he's got some splainin to do there.

Comment by Mondobubba on 12/17/2012 17:21:47
Nikki Haley replaces Jim Demint with right wing loon.

As Right Wing Watch reports, Scott is a Tea Party Republican with a record that is virtually as conservative of that of DeMint, who is one of the most far-right members of the Senate. For example, from RWW:

In the “traditional values” section of his campaign website Scott lists legislation he has supported promoting abstinence education, defunding United Nations family planning programs, imposing abortion restrictions on women in the District of Columbia, and “protecting” Christmas.