IN January 2006 I stepped off a C-130 in Tal Afar, Iraq. As I began my 13-month deployment, I imagined an American public following our progress with the same concern as my family and friends. But since returning home, I have seen that America has changed the channel.
Young investment bankers spend their impressive bonuses on clubs in Manhattan and many seem uninterested in the soldiers fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan. As a Princeton graduate and a former financial analyst, I was once a part of this world, and I like returning to it, putting the Spartan life of Tal Afar and Anbar Province behind me. But even as I enjoy time with the friends who have welcomed me home, my thoughts wander back to other friends who continue to fight as the city parties on.
Serious problems with the war in Iraq are well chronicled, but I am struck by one that does not seem to trouble the country's leadership, even though it is profoundly corrosive to our common good: the disparity between the lives of the few who are fighting and being killed, and the many who have been asked for nothing more than to continue shopping.
Those who rationalize this disconnect have argued that our soldiers are volunteers, happy doing what they signed up to do. While it is true that most soldiers are devoted to country and comrades, and are focused on their mission, the assertion that soldiers are cheerfully returning for multiple combat tours is grounded in statistics and arguments that are misleading.
Supposedly impressive re-enlistment rates are cited as evidence that soldiers enthusiastically support the war effort. In reality, these retention numbers are more the result of the "stop-loss" policy, where soldiers are required to remain in the Army after their contracts have expired if their units are deployed or ordered to deploy soon. My platoon's infantrymen expected to be "stop-lossed" and some felt they might as well cash in on the re-enlistment bonuses if they were going to be forced to stay in the Army anyway.
Few of today's soldiers expected 15-month deployments separated by home stays of less than 12 months. The stress on Army families is enormous, especially since at least four of those months at "home" are generally spent training in the field. Sacrifices like these were the norm in World War II, and families left behind could draw strength from the knowledge that everyone was in the same situation. Today's military families shoulder this burden pretty much alone.
WASHINGTON, Oct. 21 — The new chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff plans to press Congress and the public to sustain the current high levels of military spending — even after the Iraq war — arguing for money to repair and replace worn-out weapons and to restore American ground forces he described as “breakable,” though not yet broken.
The new chairman, Adm. Mike Mullen, expressed deep concerns that the long counterinsurgency missions in Iraq and Afghanistan have so consumed the military that the Army and Marine Corps may be unprepared for a high-intensity war against a major adversary.
He rejected the counsel of those who might urge immediate attacks inside Iran to destroy nuclear installations or to stop the flow of explosives that end up as powerful roadside bombs in Iraq or Afghanistan, killing American troops.
With America at war in two Muslim countries, he said, attacking a third Islamic nation in the region “has extraordinary challenges and risks associated with it.” The military option, he said, should be a last resort.
But Admiral Mullen warned any nation, including Iran, not to “mistake restraint for lack of commitment or lack of concern or lack of capability.” He described the Air Force and Navy as America’s “strategic reserve,” ready to carry out a full range of combat operations beyond Iraq and Afghanistan.
In his first interview since becoming chairman, Admiral Mullen sat in his Pentagon office on Friday and described his three immediate priorities:
Develop a military strategy for the Middle East, beyond Iraq and Afghanistan.
Accelerate efforts to “reconstitute, reset, revitalize” the armed forces, which he said meant replacing combat equipment and tending to the needs of those in uniform, in particular soldiers and marines and their families.
Refocus the military’s attention beyond the current wars to prepare for other challenges, especially along the Pacific Rim and in Africa.
Those efforts will require a considerable commitment of money, and Pentagon officials are quietly acknowledging that Congress and the public may have little appetite after Iraq for sustaining the high levels of military spending carried out since the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.
But Admiral Mullen said that an important part of his job would be making the case for maintaining those large military budgets.
“I think as a country we’re just going to have to devote more resources to national security in the world that we’re living in right now,” he said. “And I don’t do that lightly.”
“I recognize that the budget is higher now than it’s ever been,” he added, referring to the combined total of the basic annual Defense Department budget and the special supplemental budgets to pay for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Military spending is hovering around 4 percent of gross domestic product, “and I would see that in the future as an absolute floor,” Admiral Mullen said.
Quote by wickedpam: I have control over my emotions? :scratch:
Quote by Raine:
I wish, regarding these fires, that California had the national guard... :(
Quote by Raine:
Hey liv... are you listening to the news on Pheonix? Did you catch that story about Chertoff using the REal ID act to circumvent environmental laws to build the border fence? Did I hear that correctly?
Quote by wickedpam:
Did Steph just say Newlin Zeland?
Quote by Raine:
Bernard KErik, AND too much eyeliner....Those are Rudy's issues...;)
Quote by wickedpam: Wonder if Steph will drag out the "Get those puppies!" ?
Quote by BobR: Philadelphia rated least attractive city...
We all love America. We all love America. We just disagree on how we should function, what we should do, big government, small government. It doesn't mean you hate America. I think there is a handful of people who hate America. Unfortunately for them, a lot of them are losing their homes in a forest fire today. There are a few people that hate America. But I don't think the Democrats are those. I think there are those posing as Democrats that are like that.
Quote by wickedpam: Gawd! Those pix just scared the hell out of me!![]()
Quote by Raine:Funny I always got dates when I visited... :PQuote by BobR:
Philadelphia rated least attractive city...
Quote by Raine:
YAY! the perverted researchers stack!
Sexomnia! Uh oh...
Quote by livingonli:I prefer to stay awake through it. You can't really enjoy it if you're sleeping through it.Quote by Raine: YAY! the perverted researchers stack! Sexomnia! Uh oh...
Quote by Raine:IThey say, the famous *they*... that you wake up feeling great!Quote by livingonli:Quote by Raine:
YAY! the perverted researchers stack!
Sexomnia! Uh oh...
I prefer to stay awake through it. You can't really enjoy it if you're sleeping through it.
Quote by livingonli:Quote by Raine:
YAY! the perverted researchers stack!
Sexomnia! Uh oh...
I prefer to stay awake through it. You can't really enjoy it if you're sleeping through it.
Quote by Raine:
Do you think the Osmands will endorse Mitt?
Just asking...![]()
Quote by Raine:
The Mercury Diet! brought to you by the SM newscast!
Quote by livingonli:Quote by Raine:
The Mercury Diet! brought to you by the SM newscast!
And we know it works. You really, really lose weight.
Quote by livingonli: So Mrs. Roberts is like Mary Kay Letourneo only with more boys to service her needs.
Quote by starling310:
Thom is going to have a discussion with an Ayn Rand type person about banning smoking in connected houses.
Oh boy...brings back memories of a certain blog discussion on a similar topic.
![]()
:spank:
Quote by starling310:
Thom is going to have a discussion with an Ayn Rand type person about banning smoking in connected houses.
Oh boy...brings back memories of a certain blog discussion on a similar topic.
![]()
:spank:
Quote by Raine:
Rudy employs alleged molesting priest.
Quote by BobR:
The Smoking Nazis thread?... nothing like talking to a brick wall... :rolleyes2:
Quote by Raine:
Hoo haw... I am gonna go roll an organic tobacco cigarette. Cotton filters as well.Do NOT get me started!
Quote by starling310:Now, is organic tobacco technically "better?"Quote by Raine: Hoo haw... I am gonna go roll an organic tobacco cigarette. Cotton filters as well.Do NOT get me started!
Is tobacco in it's pure form carcinogenic? Or, is it all the other stuff they put in there?
Quote by Raine:Quote by starling310:Quote by Raine:
Hoo haw... I am gonna go roll an organic tobacco cigarette. Cotton filters as well.Do NOT get me started!
Now, is organic tobacco technically "better?"![]()
Is tobacco in it's pure form carcinogenic? Or, is it all the other stuff they put in there?
I will be honest with you to say that I am not sure... but I know that smoking urine Fiberglass, and ammonia are really bad things... I do not have all those extra things that the big tobacco companies put in my cigs.
I do not apologize endorse or make excuses for my habit, but smoking has been around for thousands of years.The lung cancer has become pretty rampant in the last many decades. So I do not know.
Quote by starling310: Yeah, me too. I rented a townhouse a few years back. In the townhouse next to me was a smoker. The way the building was set up, her living space was below mine. And, she would smoke ALL THE TIME.....and it would come in through our living and bed room windows. I smoke. But, I couldn't STAND IT!!! It was constant. Because of that experience, I try to be cognisent of my own smoking habits. I do smoke on my deck on occassion and I live in a condo. I feel slightly bad, because I wonder if it bothers my neighbors. Again, it's occassional; not every 15 minutes throughout the day. But, I don't do things like walk through the common areas, including the laundry room, like some people choose to do and it pisses me off! [/rant]
Quote by starling310: I can say that I don't know what my reaction would be if my neighbor said "Hey could you not smoke outside?" I'd like to believe I'd say "Sure! No problem." But, if a friend stops by and we are having a beer, I want to be able to step out onto the deck and smoke. I don't want to smoke in my house, because it lingers. Outside, it does eventually dissipate. This is a tough one. I couldn't broach the subject last time. Everyone was just too "yelly" n' stuff.![]()
Quote by Raine:I am sorry, I was one of those yelly folks.Quote by starling310:
I can say that I don't know what my reaction would be if my neighbor said "Hey could you not smoke outside?"
I'd like to believe I'd say "Sure! No problem." But, if a friend stops by and we are having a beer, I want to be able to step out onto the deck and smoke.
I don't want to smoke in my house, because it lingers. Outside, it does eventually dissipate.
This is a tough one. I couldn't broach the subject last time. Everyone was just too "yelly" n' stuff.
![]()
But you see this is a real issue. Smoking outside... that really broaches a freedom issue for me. no one owns to outdoors.
Quote by Raine:
I think it is my thought to go outside.
I do. I smoke inside only when I am at a smoking establsihment.
Yes it is tricky. I am rather skepical of what thomm is saying about shooting up and cooking brownies... Shooting up may tend to make getting aids more likely...
Quote by wickedpam: Question - If Thom, or others, have an issue about the aresolization of it all how does he feel about perfumes? I have a neighbor who baths in some horrible perfume that gags me when she stands upwind of our house. Is she then breaking a law because I can smell it in the house?
Quote by Raine:
Well yes, we are poluting the air... and I do not minmize that, but look around... cars... buildings...
I just just think that Thomms argument is sortof a non starter.
Quote by Raine:Quote by wickedpam:
Question - If Thom, or others, have an issue about the aresolization of it all how does he feel about perfumes? I have a neighbor who baths in some horrible perfume that gags me when she stands upwind of our house. Is she then breaking a law because I can smell it in the house?
Great point. So is it what is oput in the air or what is put in a persons body?
Quote by Raine:
I want to know why the government can't regulate tobacco. Why can't they make it illegal to put chemicals into tobacco?
They did it for lead in paint... the did it with asbestos...
Quote by starling310:Right! And, again it's like a Circular Reference arguement. Everyone has the same opinion that it's "my air." So, who is more right? In my opinion, there's no real way to know whose air it is "more." I do think Thom has a good point about the Tobacco companies and wouldn't it be nice, if we could just puff on pure tobacco, with NO CHEMICALS in it? Mmmm......Quote by Raine: Well yes, we are poluting the air... and I do not minmize that, but look around... cars... buildings... I just just think that Thomms argument is sortof a non starter.
Quote by starling310:Quote by Raine:Quote by wickedpam:
Question - If Thom, or others, have an issue about the aresolization of it all how does he feel about perfumes? I have a neighbor who baths in some horrible perfume that gags me when she stands upwind of our house. Is she then breaking a law because I can smell it in the house?
Great point. So is it what is oput in the air or what is put in a persons body?
I think Thom would argue that someone's perfume scent can't kill you second hand.
Not that we know of yet, anyway.
;)
Quote by starling310:I think Thom would argue that someone's perfume scent can't kill you second hand. Not that we know of yet, anyway. ;)Quote by Raine:Great point. So is it what is oput in the air or what is put in a persons body?Quote by wickedpam: Question - If Thom, or others, have an issue about the aresolization of it all how does he feel about perfumes? I have a neighbor who baths in some horrible perfume that gags me when she stands upwind of our house. Is she then breaking a law because I can smell it in the house?
Quote by starling310: Go Organic to quit smoking? Hey, Raine, how's that workin' out for ya! :rofl:
Quote by Raine:
I want to know why the government can't regulate tobacco. Why can't they make it illegal to put chemicals into tobacco?
They did it for lead in paint... the did it with asbestos...
Quote by starling310:We do it with cars! I guess the only good analogy to smoking I can come up with is driving, and fumes from driving. Let's say you live in NYC....there is no "need" to drive, just as there is no "need" to smoke. So, you walk everywhere! You'll sometimes walk 12 blocks to get a sandwich. Good job, by the way, that's a long haul. Now, should you "have " to breathe in fumes from cars? They don't "need" to be driving. But, they are driving and it affects you; the walker. So, government steps in and says D'Aaaalright! the fumes coming out of the tail pipes can't be really, really bad! Yes, why can't they do that for the ciggies?Quote by Raine: I want to know why the government can't regulate tobacco. Why can't they make it illegal to put chemicals into tobacco? They did it for lead in paint... the did it with asbestos...
Quote by starling310: Yup...we are very much the villians. I get a lot of crap because I don't eat meat for the environmental and ethical reasons but "you still smoke?" Well, yes. Yes, I do. I never know how to respond to THAT comment. Sheesh.
Quote by Raine:I say it is at least something.Quote by starling310:
Yup...we are very much the villians.
I get a lot of crap because I don't eat meat for the environmental and ethical reasons but "you still smoke?" Well, yes. Yes, I do. I never know how to respond to THAT comment. Sheesh.
Fuck sometimes it seams like those of us that do a little something are suddenly hypocrites becuase we aren't doing everything.
Well hell. if only everyone did a little something...
Then half of our problems would go away. THEN and only then can we go to work to tackle the other half.
*sigh*
Quote by starling310:
Howabout people who bring their crying babies into work?And, everyone gathers and coos and goo goos at them for an hour?
Are they infringing on my right to work in PEACE and QUIET!?!?
Starling regrets that this may sound like she hates babies. And, she does not.
Quote by starling310:
Mala!
![]()
Quote by starling310: Howabout people who bring their crying babies into work?And, everyone gathers and coos and goo goos at them for an hour? Are they infringing on my right to work in PEACE and QUIET!?!? Starling regrets that this may sound like she hates babies. And, she does not.
Quote by wickedpam:Quote by starling310:
Mala!
![]()
Well I did! :p
Quote by Raine:I say it is at least something.Quote by starling310:
Yup...we are very much the villians.
I get a lot of crap because I don't eat meat for the environmental and ethical reasons but "you still smoke?" Well, yes. Yes, I do. I never know how to respond to THAT comment. Sheesh.
Fuck sometimes it seams like those of us that do a little something are suddenly hypocrites becuase we aren't doing everything.
Well hell. if only everyone did a little something...
Then half of our problems would go away. THEN and only then can we go to work to tackle the other half.
*sigh*
Quote by starling310:He is, in fact, alive. Most likely, sitting in hia bathrobe at a metal, avacado green kitchen table, talking on a wall mounted phone.Quote by wickedpam:Well I did! :pQuote by starling310: Mala!![]()
I kid. That was a nice interview.
Quote by TriSec: Oh, poop. I broke the blog, didn't I? :kickcan:
Quote by BobR:
Stark Apologizes
Christ...![]()
Quote by BobR: Stark Apologizes Christ...![]()
I hope that with this apology, I will become as insignificant as I should be....
Quote by Raine:What the hell is wrong with these people!Quote by BobR:
Stark Apologizes
Christ...![]()
Fuckity fuck fuck.
Randi will be apoplectic today.
Quote by TriSec:
Trying again...
TriSec in the left-hand seat over the Hudson
Quote by BobR: For Mr. Tri: ---> :prince:![]()
Quote by TriSec:I hope that with this apology, I will become as insignificant as I should be....
Yes, you have indeed, Mr. Stark.
F*ckers.
Quote by Raine:
GEez, 750 homes lost. :(
this is wretched. This is what global warming looks like.
Quote by TriSec:Speaking of which, has anyone heard from Zowie elsewhere on the internets? This is pretty close to home now...Quote by Raine: GEez, 750 homes lost. :( this is wretched. This is what global warming looks like.
Quote by starling310:![]()
By abe on 10/21/2007 at 6:51 p.m.
I wonder just how today's fires in that part of the county will play on the upcoming recall elecions and those dreaded absentee ballots, with all those people being, unfortunately, evacuated.
Quote by starling310: Present. You looking for someone specific?
Quote by TriSec: :ph34r: I reread your post from yesterday, Raine. There's a comment added to the Blackwater story that rather leaps out at me now...By abe on 10/21/2007 at 6:51 p.m. I wonder just how today's fires in that part of the county will play on the upcoming recall elecions and those dreaded absentee ballots, with all those people being, unfortunately, evacuated.
Quote by Raine:Quote by starling310:
Present.
You looking for someone specific?
Could use a little help in a few threads... mainly the 2 year old swiftbaot thread adn the newest torture thread.
Quote by Raine:if I may assume that was for me... I accept it wholeheartedly, andQuote by starling310:
![]()
back.
And mala and Liv, I do not think I have hugged you guys lately either... :hug:
Quote by livingonli:
I should send the Z man a PM. He spent the last two Octobers in New York. I know he was talking about the October 27th protest but for the LA side so I don't know if he came east this year. We didn't have our Laura bloggers meet-up this year.
Quote by BobR:Quote by livingonli:
I should send the Z man a PM. He spent the last two Octobers in New York. I know he was talking about the October 27th protest but for the LA side so I don't know if he came east this year. We didn't have our Laura bloggers meet-up this year.
Last I heard from him (a few days ago), he is in NYC, but doesn't have much in the way of internet access.
Quote by wickedpam::hug:'s all around!Quote by Raine:if I may assume that was for me... I accept it wholeheartedly, andQuote by starling310:![]()
back. And mala and Liv, I do not think I have hugged you guys lately either... :hug:
Quote by Raine:
ooh.. I will look for them. I am not sure if I get that on comcast, liv.
Quote by Mondobubba: Hey we got more comments here than at the other blog.![]()
![]()